Poll: Rated R vs. BEYONCÉ

Daydream

Both the most personal albums from Rihanna and Beyoncé. Which is your favorite of the two?

Mad House -v- Pretty Hurts
Wait Your Turn -v- Haunted
Hard -v- Drunk In Love
Stupid In Love -v- Blow
Rockstar 101 -v- No Angel
Russian Roulette -v- Partition
Fire Bomb -v- Jealous
Rude Boy -v- Rocket
Photographs -v- Mine
G4L -v- XO
Te Amo -v- ***Flawless
Cold Case Love -v- Superpower
The Last Song -v- Heaven -v- Blue

BajanBeauty

Hmm idk if I would consider Beyoncé that personal in comparison to Rated R.
- 4 would be a better choice imo

But if you were gonna do a visual comparison of videos. I think they're comparable.

Retro

Mad House -v- Pretty Hurts
Wait Your Turn -v- Haunted
Hard -v- Drunk In Love
Stupid In Love -v- Blow
Rockstar 101 -v- No Angel
Russian Roulette -v- Partition
Fire Bomb -v- Jealous
Rude Boy -v- Rocket
Photographs -v- Mine
G4L -v- XO
Te Amo -v- ***Flawless
Cold Case Love -v- Superpower
The Last Song -v- Heaven -v- Blue

Fenty The Great

Why

Mad House -v- Pretty Hurts
Wait Your Turn -v- Haunted
Hard -v- Drunk In Love
Stupid In Love -v- Blow
Rockstar 101 -v- No Angel
Russian Roulette -v- Partition
Fire Bomb -v- Jealous
Rude Boy -v- Rocket
Photographs -v- Mine
G4L -v- XO
Te Amo -v- ***Flawless
Cold Case Love -v- Superpower
The Last Song -v- Heaven -v- Blue

posh

Rated R is Rih's best album and BEYONCE is Bey's worst so.. easy winner.

BKTweets12

Everything on BEYONCÉ expect..
Fire Bomb & Cold Case Love >>

Jet

BEYONCE for all of them, Rated R is Rihs worst album

Daydream

Mad House -v- Pretty Hurts
Wait Your Turn -v- Haunted
Hard -v- Drunk In Love
Stupid In Love -v- Blow
Rockstar 101 -v- No Angel
Russian Roulette -v- Partition
Fire Bomb -v- Jealous
Rude Boy -v- Rocket
Photographs -v- Mine
G4L -v- XO
Te Amo -v- ***Flawless
Cold Case Love -v- Superpower
The Last Song -v- Heaven -v- Blue

So hard. Both albums are so good.

helloDer

BEYONCE easily. I only use Russian Roulette and Rude Boy off RR. I use all but 3 songs off BEYONCE

DG1

Mad House -v- Pretty Hurts
Wait Your Turn -v- Haunted
Hard -v- Drunk In Love
Stupid In Love -v- Blow
Rockstar 101 -v- No Angel
Russian Roulette -v- Partition
Fire Bomb -v- Jealous
Rude Boy -v- Rocket
Photographs -v- Mine
G4L -v- XO
Te Amo -v- ***Flawless
Cold Case Love -v- Superpower
The Last Song -v- Heaven -v- Blue

BadBitch

Mad House -v- Pretty Hurts
Wait Your Turn -v- Haunted
Hard -v- Drunk In Love
Stupid In Love -v- Blow
Rockstar 101 -v- No Angel
Russian Roulette -v- Partition
Fire Bomb -v- Jealous
Rude Boy -v- Rocket
Photographs -v- Mine
G4L -v- XO
Te Amo -v- ***Flawless
Cold Case Love -v- Superpower
The Last Song -v- Heaven -v- Blue (too hard)

Beyonce: 7
Rated R: 5

50thStateofMind

I don't think I can vote yet..

Rated R is Rihanna's best album and Beyonce is still really fresh (albeit AMAZING)

Haunter

Mad House -v- Pretty Hurts
Wait Your Turn -v- Haunted
Hard -v- Drunk In Love
Stupid In Love -v- Blow
Rockstar 101-v- No Angel
Russian Roulette -v- Partition
Fire Bomb -v- Jealous
Rude Boy -v- Rocket
Photographs -v- Mine
G4L -v- XO
Te Amo -v- ***Flawless
Cold Case Love -v- Superpower
The Last Song -v- Heaven -v- Blue

RomanNavy

Well this is easy.

Rihanna wins for everything. Even Beyonce's 'best' work can't beat the flawless RR

IHeartIdol

I don't even think a track-by-track comparison is necessary. Rated R is Rihanna's best album with every track either being flawless or near-flawless whereas Beyoncé is probably Bey's weakest record to date. Maybe I need time for Yoncé to resonate with me this time around, but for now Rated R wins by a landslide.

Taemira

Mad House -v- Pretty Hurts
Wait Your Turn -v- Haunted
Hard -v- Drunk In Love
Stupid In Love -v- Blow
Rockstar 101 -v- No Angel
Russian Roulette -v- Partition
Fire Bomb -v- Jealous
Rude Boy -v- Rocket
~~Photographs -v- Mine~~
G4L -v- XO
Te Amo -v- ***Flawless
Cold Case Love -v- Superpower
The Last Song -v- Heaven -v- Blue

Rated Regend.

MCBeth

Mad House -v- Pretty Hurts
Wait Your Turn -v- Haunted
Hard -v- Drunk In Love
Stupid In Love -v- Blow
Rockstar 101 -v- No Angel
Russian Roulette -v- Partition
Fire Bomb -v- Jealous
Rude Boy -v- Rocket

Photographs -v- Mine
G4L -v- XO
Te Amo -v- ***Flawless
Cold Case Love -v- Superpower
The Last Song -v- Heaven -v- Blue

Rated R is Rihanna's best work but BEYONCÉ easily.

cats&fashion

Mad House -v- Pretty Hurts
Wait Your Turn -v- Haunted
Hard -v- Drunk In Love
Stupid In Love -v- Blow
Rockstar 101 -v- No Angel
Russian Roulette -v- Partition
Fire Bomb -v- Jealous
Rude Boy -v- Rocket
Photographs -v- Mine
G4L -v- XO
Te Amo -v- ***Flawless
Cold Case Love -v- Superpower
The Last Song -v- Heaven -v- Blue
If Rated R is so much better than BEYONCE, than why didn't the critical reception reflect that?

prayer

Rated R is my favorite album of all time. So that. But Beyoncé is the best album in years.

IHeartIdol

Quote:

Originally posted by cats&fashion

If Rated R is so much better than BEYONCE, than why didn't the critical reception reflect that?

Critics are humans too though. Their opinion is just that - an opinion. The quality of music cannot be measured through quantitative means like Metacritic scores. Or at least it shouldn't.