Quote:
Originally posted by Raiden
Of course Nicole is the better judge - she invented One Direction.
What did Sheryl do that can compare? Heck, what did Louis Walsh do that can compare?
|
Quote:
Originally posted by Inverted
And Nicole is responsible for the actual biggest act that the X Factor franchise (in any country) has launched.
As for success, Nicole has seen success in her life and it's not just one country in the world. She's still a recognizable face to many while Cheryl is just a local star.
|
I agree with these! Nicole was a driving force behind 1D which is more than Cheryl achieved.
Acts such as One Direction, Cher Lloyd and Wagner and the press and hype surrounding them- as well as high profile performances like Gaga and Bad Romance- gave the X Factor their views during their peak.
In all honesty, and to agree with Louis, Nicole IS better than Cheryl at judging. No shade, but I can't recall one true, memorable crowning achievement that Cheryl managed to have during her tenure. She had Alexandra Burke (and it was Beyoncé that really drove that "moment"), but hasn't Alexandra already said Cheryl had minimal interaction with her during the show and chose not to keep in touch after the show?
what kind of weak way to get some nasty response
a bit ironic, at least cheryl has never tried