Season 1

S2 takes the hugest **** on S1's existence.

AHS is one of the few shows who gets better with every season.COVEN>Asylum>First season.

I'm rewatching Season 1 and it pales in comparison to the flawlessness of Seasons 2 & 3
The quality of the season is clearly proportional to how much screen time Jessica Lange gets

Season 2 sh*ts all over season 1

NO WAY Murder House is better than Asylum. Asylum is a ****ing television masterpiece.

Season 2 was so dark and disturbing, it was hard for me to watch alot of the time, I may try rewatching it on Netflix. I love season 1 though and Connie Britton

Season 2>Season3>Season 1

Season 1 was ****ing amazing but the last 2 seasons made me realise that the first one does not compete at all.The second one takes the cake because it disturbed me every single episode.
It was the only season that truly put the horror in American Horror Story

The first one was more scarier, which doesn't mean better, the second one was more about intrigue

Season 2>
But it was a complete mess tho, so many storylines were left untold.

S3 > S1 > S2

This!

I absolutely love both but S2 is definitely better than S1.

So far S2 > S1 >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> S3