Discussion: Is Christina the Mariah of this decade? - Page 5

Madam X

Quote:

Originally posted by RaeseanLohan

Where's the impact?

And PLEASE don't come with that "People sing her songs on talent shows!!!!"

I don't feel like writing an essay, Wiki skims the surface on that here: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Christina_Aguilera#Legacy

ethann.

Quote:

Originally posted by Alexz

Christina is a Max Martin electro-pop tart.

Who can do this

of course
And let's not make shady digs at your fave

Giselle

Quote:

Originally posted by Xtina Culture

I don't feel like writing an essay, Wiki skims the surface on that here: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Christina_Aguilera#Legacy

Not a wikipedia section

I genuinely think she's a musical genius and a risk taker and an incredible artist. She's taught me a lot of things. But that doesn't equate to impact. That wiki article doesn't really say much, as all it does is basically talk about her old chart success and the fact that she has a nice voice.

Chrome

The Xtina stans were so messy in this thread.

Madam X

Quote:

Originally posted by RaeseanLohan

Not a wikipedia section

Not you thinking I would waste time writing paragraphs disproving of your uneducated opinion. I don't live vicariously through artists, like yourself. How sad.

Giselle

Quote:

Originally posted by Xtina Culture

Not you thinking I would waste time writing paragraphs disproving of your uneducated opinion. I don't live vicariously through artists success, like yourself. How sad.

Alright sis

Madam X

Quote:

Originally posted by RaeseanLohan

Alright sis

I am confident in my opinion that I don't feel the need to justify myself. Believe what you want. I remain unbothered by your attempts.

Meredy

Quote:

Originally posted by gotintoririfever1

Actually Christina is in her own lane. She got madonna's creativity and vision, she is alike with mariah's power and range, she got aretha and etta's soul, she can bust a move like paula if she improved her dancing, she got the beauty and charm like marilyn. She is so versatile that she could reign any genre if she wanted to but she didn't want to hog the spotlight. Christina is basically the bearer of all talents in the music industry.

No. The problem with Christina is that she got lost. They were trying to make her the combination of Mariah and Madonna, she got successful for a while but she was never the #1 pop girl. It's a common knowledge in the general public how Britney and Gaga overshadowed her existence.

Meredy

Also, Christina has never reached Mariah's level. Compare their album sales

. /end

Gold

Quote:

Originally posted by seanoh

I hope she pulls an Emancipation and is able to continue that kind of success! I love her.

THIS!!

T.C

Quote:

Originally posted by ethann.

I love Whitney and she's another one of the best vocalists ever, no need to be shaaadeee now

Whitney and Mariah are leagues above Legend X. I like X very much but she is nowhere near their level vocally, there's really no debate, sorry.

Giselle

Quote:

Originally posted by Xtina Culture

I am confident in my opinion that I don't feel the need to justify myself. Believe what you want. I remain unbothered by your attempts.

The fumes disagree

angel_ex

Quote:

Originally posted by Under_My_Skin

I love how Christina is "The Voice of This Generation" when Justin Timberlake coined it for her

Good thing only her Stans believe it

This is true. This Voice of The Generation title is a publicity stunt from her team. Too bad the public ain't picking it up.

And No. Sure, they have similarities but Christina cannot and never will match Mariah's impact.

zach

Quote:

Originally posted by Under_My_Skin

I love how Christina is "The Voice of This Generation" when Justin Timberlake coined it for her

Good thing only her Stans believe it

Justin never made that up!

Euphoria

Quote:

Originally posted by Damien M

Lmao no, Xtina = Paula Abdul
Mariah didn't flop into complete oblivion after only two albums

Back To Basics...

EJQL8

lol no. All of Mariah's studio albums are certified while Christina.... :lol: