Well it was a close one! Perfect Lover got 15 votes and Heaven On Earth got 14 so Perfect Lover is OUT!
1. Gimme More
2. Piece Of Me
3. Radar
4. Break The Ice
5. Heaven On Earth
6. Get Naked (I Got A Plan)
7. Freakshow
8. Toy Soldier
9. Hot As Ice
10. Ooh Ooh Baby 11. Perfect Lover Round 1
12. Why Should I Be Sad
, it's so hard to vote