Most people do prefer something pretty or sexy though. Let's not pretend we don't like when our faves are all dolled up.

Even a large proportion of Gaga stans despised the BTW/ARTPOP covers because they weren't pretty and everyone knows it.

OOTB > TF

TFM > TD

Prism >>>>>>> that mess

Gaga 3/3. It would be different with Born This Way tho.



So sig worthy.

As if it would even be shocking.
This is ATRL where most people stan for the good looking pop girls. There's so much shallowness in pop music and fandoms. It's not like it's new.

I don't think ATRL stans for those girls because they are good looking, I think they do it because of the music.

Of course that counts too. But if they made the exact same music and were ugly it would not be the same.

You're not really telling me looks do not matter at all. That's a damn lie.

OMG I stan Gaga more than Katy but I voted for all of Katy's covers. A true mess.

Katy just ALWAYS has amazing covers. And none of Gaga's are bad by any means, but I just prefer Katy's.

If you'd selected the EP version of The Fame Monster rather than the re-release cover, I'd probably have chosen that over Teenage Dream.

And WTF where the hell is Born This Way vs. The Complete Confection?

I prefer Katy's.

By era:
The Fame > One Of The Boys
Teenage Dream > The Fame Monster
Prism > Artpop

Overall:
Teenage Dream > The Fame > One Of The Boys > Prism = The Fame Monster > Artpop

Katy > Gaga

Katy's first two album covers are really good.

The Fame Monster is my favorite from Gaga.

Actually, I would've done the GaGa cycle vs Teenage Dream and TFM vs TCC since they're both like add ons to the parent/previous albums.

The One of the Boys and Teenage Dream covers are PERFECTION!

Katy covers are so bad

This!!

Well that is not true because Gaga has the most fans and she is not pretty according to yall ^^