Originally posted by Bert. I feel sorry for Brandy. It's like she just can't be a really GOOD singer but she really tries, ya know?

Originally posted by Sláy Bey should be able to sing in the whistle register.

Originally posted by BnPac Should? According to what laws? Is it a tare that Barbara Streisand and Whitney don't sing in the whistle register too? This thread is full of kiis. Really Beyhive let this go, I'm now convinced they are trolling.

I think Brandy and Beyonce balance in singing talent.

Beyonce's has a margin of 1 semi note over Brandy's range. Beyonce has more power in her upper register. However Beyoncé needs reverb to take away from the shrillness of her higher notes using her chest voice.

Brandy has more clarity and power in her lower range. She has very good agility. But not only are her runs amazing, she knows how to incorporate minors, which is very risky, and she always pulls it off (Bey has been able to incorporate minors but there are very few instances where she has). However her voice thins in her higher register.

Which is why in my eyes they are equal in vocal talent. But just because Brandy has a more soulful voice (imo) and is better at running, I said 1+1 would have worked better for her. It's not a diss to Beyoncé what so ever.

Originally posted by Javan kalsdnakjlsnf. She better sit on those mic effects for her life And kii @ impressive register when during the lowest note she was supposed in halo ("make a sound"). She turned the mic off into the audience because she couldn't handle it. The self drag

Originally posted by BnPac Oh so you were talking about emotion all that time? Oh then we will live it at that. Sidenote : Beyoncé is a Tina like performer of course but she is not a Tina like singer. I disagree with all your post but it's not worth it.

Originally posted by Sláy That's my point. You took it out of context for a kii. In context what I said made sense. Just because Bran is a contralto does not mean she will automatically sing as low as Toni.

Originally posted by Javan I mean. Hive like to through around there broken logic all the time but as soon as it doesn't work for them, the logic then becomes trolling

Originally posted by Ressti Acoustic I love her lower register And in concert 2009 2013 And again I love how she can just access all her registers so beautifully

ALRIGHT, THIS IS THE TRUTH AND NONE OF YOU WILL DENY IT.

Beyonce and Brandy should never be mentioned in the same sentence. Not because one is better than the other, but because they possess different voices and in no way sing similar music (these days, at least).

Beyonce has one of best trained voices I've ever heard. Her vocal technique is very precise. Her range is out of this world and she even sounds amazing when sick. Her voice is incredibly consistent.

Example #1


HOWEVER, Beyonce gives not an ounce of emotion when she sings. I actually receive no emotion from Beyonce as a person, nothing she has done or said has given me chills OTHER than watching her perform. Her insane amount of confidence carries her, and as a star it should but there is nothing there. I'm bored watching her stand and perform.


NOW BRANDY
She may not have the range, she may not have that huge star power but she has the voice to move people as it does derive from church, and that is evident and to deny her talent is just wrong. Her voice is definitely unique and has grown so much over the years. Her runs are an essential part of her performance and are studied by today's biggest stars within the r&b world. She can stand and for hours and sing and I will not be able to turn away. You can't deny the emotion in her voice.




Just quit the comparisons, Brandy is obviously just singing the song for fun and is not trying to convince anyone that she is better than Beyonce. These are two women who have nothing but love for one another, so please, just cut it out.

Originally posted by WheresJay ALRIGHT, THIS IS THE TRUTH AND NONE OF YOU WILL DENY IT. Beyonce and Brandy should never be mentioned in the same sentence. Not because one is better than the other, but because they possess different voices and in no way sing similar music (these days, at least). Beyonce has one of best trained voices I've ever heard. Her vocal technique is very precise. Her range is out of this world and she even sounds amazing when sick. Her voice is incredibly consistent. Example #1 HOWEVER, Beyonce gives not an ounce of emotion when she sings. I actually receive no emotion from Beyonce as a person, nothing she has done or said has given me chills OTHER than watching her perform. Her insane amount of confidence carries her, and as a star it should but there is nothing there. I'm bored watching her stand and perform. NOW BRANDY She may not have the range, she may not have that huge star power but she has the voice to move people as it does derive from church, and that is evident. Her voice is definitely unique and has grown so much over the years. Her runs are an essential part of her performance and are studied by today's biggest stars within the r&b world. She can stand and for hours and sing and I will not be able to turn away. You can't deny the emotion in her voice. Just quit the comparisons, Brandy is obviously just singing the song for fun and is not trying to convince anyone that she is better than Beyonce. These are two women who have nothing but love for one another, so please, just cut it out.

Originally posted by Sláy That's my point. You took it out of context for a kii. In context what I said made sense. Just because Bran is a contralto does not mean she will automatically sing as low as Toni.

Originally posted by Ressti So much clarity in her higher register too. The scales, the low notes, the clear, full and resonant F5's Her higher register is truly impressive. She makes it look easy. It must be for her 'cause she can serve it in uptempo Jazz and in Rock 'n Roll style. Shrill

Yes shrill. Listen to that awful forced note she hit @ 1:32 when she was scatting.

There was a lot of shrillness that whole performance tbh, and it's funny that it's most noticeable without reverbs

Originally posted by Ressti Lol @ foggy being re-used as an argument everytime someone posts Bey's resonant lower register you can even hear it on a low quality 240p video taken by a phone in the nosebleed section while the crowd is roaring. Foggy

Originally posted by BnPac I misread that comment, my bad and it's obvious by my reply. And I'm certainly not a delusional Beyhive, never have been. Not once did I compared Bey with Bran in this thread. So you can keep that next comment about "bey is flawless" bs. But most of you guys comments here seem like trolling. But then again maybe you guys really consider that emotion if part of vocal technique or vocal abilities. You never know.