Miley is the one who is mentally sane, one would expect a better behavior from her and excuse some words from Sinead who is battling a mental issue.

Exactly - she was wrong too and hope someone tells her in person.

Miley have never cussed her Hannah Montana days wtf are you talking about. She said in her MTV documentary that she would never do that. Get your facts straight and young girls should be looking up to their mothers not a 20 year old woman who is still finding herself

Kids are going to do whatever they want, regardless of Miley's antics. They're going to do drugs, have sex, cuss or whatever rebellious thing they can think of because we all go through that phase. Miley isn't their parents and shouldn't have to live like it. If kids look up to her, that's their decision. She didn't force them to do that & now all of a sudden she's going back on her word.

Clearly you didn't watch her documentary where she made an entire point about how Hannah Montana will always be a big part of her life & she'll never regret doing it.

The letter was offensive, mental illness or not. To judge Miley's life and say she's heading towards rehab for just going nude is.. 90% of the industry uses sex to sell, but now it's a problem when Miley jumps on the trend? Not buying it. We've already established that Miley's response was wrong, but the Sinead supporters can't honestly think she's 100% right.

I love how situations like this always come up when an album is about to drop...

Perfect publicity. Got all the children talking.

Amanda Bynes was REALLY rude to Miley a few months ago and called her ugly and whatnot. So why can't Miley use her name whenever she wants to? Amanda was extremely rude, so why can't Miley do the same to Amanda?

Sinead stays trying. I lova ha music but she had no place going in on Miley out of the blue, **** shaming ha and what not. Bitch betta stay in ha lane. Miley need not take lessons from anyone, especially cloaked unrequested advice.

Amanda was calling everyone ugly even the ones in her apartment bulding and she's mentally ill.

And just cause Miley was insulted does not give her the right to name drop Amanda that was months ago. Let it go it only makes you look petty.

In terms of Sinead her response to Miley can not be defended.

all this is gettng messier

Uhmmm Sinead is an out of shape one hit wonder and is only doing this crap to get into the news Miley should have said this as well

All of this.

Sinhead should not have written the letter in the first place. Have your opinion but honestly at the end of the day it's her life and it's not your place to say what she should and shouldn't do. It was immature.

But what Miley did was much worse. There is no excuse for making fun of mental illness. And why did she need to make fun of Amanda in the process? It is hurtful, immature and unnecessary honestly. Mental illness is a serious issue and this sort of ignorance REALLY annoys me. I love her but what she did was wrong. Point blank. She could have gone about it so much better.

I'm not on either side because frankly, neither are in the right. I'm sick of hearing about this whole thing.

Amanda called her ugly Miley is allowed to call her a crazy person. Its true.

OMG! Some people here are just

This. Sinead was harsh but what Miley did was disgusting. You guys have no idea what it's like to to have mental illness. I can't believe some people here are defending Miley.

You need to grow up.

Who died & made Sinead the moral authority?!? Sinead had no business **** shamming Miley. Once she did that, it was open season! If she was so concerned about Miley she could have contacted Miley privately. During her prime, When Madonna was busy exploiting her sexuality in the early 90s, where was her protesting?