What part of "Miley hasn't either. And besides, most people with schizophrenia have intact moral capacities. They know what they're doing is wrong. So to absolve Amanda Bynes of any moral responsibility is ridiculous." had to do with Rihanna?

Rihanna has never attacked people for being mentally ill. Miley has. Twice in one fell swoop, in fact.

DRAG HA

Being dragged on a forum by nobodies doesn't equal being dragged on twitter by a celebrity with 14 million followers. Not that it's right in the first case though.

And you've reduced the entire message of the letter to being called a *****, when sunshine and roses were mostly what was in the letter.

Nah, I'm just playing these tweets are WAY out of line

I was literally talking about how I didn't agree with Sinead with my boyfriend and then these tweets show up. Damnit celebrities

Do you say it cause that's the experience you've had with your fave throughout the years?

LOL. You are so damn pressed by Miley ha impact. Coming in this thread without even liking her posting more than anybody else. But don't worry, it's all ok to be basically called a label ***** who has no self respect in an open letter by someone who is not capable of having the own life in check. Move on and make a Kimbra thread.

Miley's response is the most ratchet thing I've seen.
How dare she. Sinead was being real with her. She's such an ignorant spoilt brat.

If Miley is going to get mad at every negative thing that's said about her, she'd better stop doing these things. Her "I don't care what people think" attitude is negative by showing that she cares what people think by insulting them back.

Technically no one knows what Amanda Byrnes has. That article was written by radar online which notoriously known for lying. Her parents have released a statement saying that anything written about Amanda is not to be taken seriously unless released by their lawyer.

Can't believe people are ACTUALLY defending Miley. How... I don't understand.

It wasn't negative. She was empowering her to not prostitute herself (which is what she is doing) & use her talent. She called her very talented more than once. I can't with people missing the point of the letter.

The defense of Rihanna involved two claims:

1. That Rihanna was justified because she didn't start the fight.
2. That Rihanna was justified in attacking those people because they weren't mentally ill (and consequently had moral responsibility for what they did).

I then claimed that Miley never started a fight and that even if those people were mentally ill, they weren't completely absolved of moral responsibility. Hope that clears everything up for you.

Oh, so #hardcore! So #thug! Destiny Hope Cyrus 4 Prez!

Could you possibly given a more generic response?

"LOL"
"You are so pressed"
"Miley ha impact"
"you post more than her stans"

It will catch up with you. Just wait and see Miley.

Sinead was even real with her and so honest. Miley is a bit*h.

You're an idiot.
Did you even read the letter?
Sinead O'Connor is one of the few people to have seen both the top and bottom of the music industry & she was being real with her. That letter is far more valuable than anything she'll get from her kiss-ass employees or manager. She is being 100% honest with her & telling her she doesn't need to prostitute herself (which she is doing) when she is as talented as she is.

So she could stop papers contacting her to make a statement.
She said it in the letter.

Once again with the complete and often inaccurate strawman and ad hominem. There's really no point in even trying to discuss this with you because all you're going to do is blatantly ignore my completely reasonable points and say "lol u & ur favez r flopz!!!!" Like, how old are you? Ugh.

Did you even read the letter aside from the points where Sinead gave her advice? As has been mentioned elsewhere in the thread, Sinead was very respectful and even called her "talented" multiple times in the piece. But you are so goddamn pressed that all you can see are the (not even misplaced) negative parts, and even those weren't even being critical of Miley but rather her handlers. Get a grip.

I didn't even dislike her before now. I didn't like her new music or persona but until this moment I liked her as a person. Now I really can't even say anything positive about her.