Poll: Who's more natural at Rock? Gaga or Ke$ha? - Page 6

BritneysDaddy

Quote:

Originally posted by collin

He's not still making music, you really think he knows about Ke$ha?

Iggy Pop and The Flaming Lips are both arguably bigger rock icons. But ok, miss.

/endthread

the hell kinda ignorant statement?

Not only is KISS STILL making music, they are also STILL touring and performing in stadiums for thousands. He's obviously aware of the music industry... if he knows Gaga he knows Ke$ha.

Cherry

Quote:

Originally posted by collin

Laughing because Ke$ha collaborated with rock legends, The Flaming Lips and Iggy Pop, on Warrior...
and yet Gaga wins this poll. Welcome to ATRL.

Ke$ha - Die Young
Gaga - You And I

And you can list celebs saying whatever you want, but Ke$ha has been praised infinitely by The Flaming Lips and Iggy Pop... and Gaga has been called, by Gene Simmons and other places, the only true rockstar of our generation. If Ke$ha were relevant maybe she would've been, too. And their opinions >>> Brian May.

The Flaming Lips and Iggy Pop are not legends

But the Rolling Stones are

And "Die Young" is not rock at all, in the slightest, in any way, shape, or form. It's a generic dance-pop song. The delusion is real

Welcome to ATRL indeed.

Bríseis

Quote:

Originally posted by Cherry

The Flaming Lips and Iggy Pop are not legends

But the Rolling Stones are

And "Die Young" is not rock at all, in the slightest, in any way, shape, or form. It's a generic dance-pop song. The delusion is real

Welcome to ATRL indeed.

The delusion and ignorance is real... only on ATRL indeed.

Phil

My fave

Georges

Quote:

Originally posted by Cherry

"Party at a Rich Dude's House", "Gold Trans Am", and whatever other pseudo-rock she's released is not rock music. Not that that was even the question. The question was who is more natural at rock and roll, and it's obvious that with her vocal talent and stage presence, Gaga is. She can do rock very well live and has performed with - or at the very least, been praised by - many of the rock greats.

She did work with The Flaming Lips, Alice Cooper and Iggy Pop

Georges

Ke$ha has a better voice for rock.

She worked with a lot of rock acts too.

Aurora

I wouldn't normally say this, but... I'm about to spill the true tea, y'all.

Keep in mind that I'm a stan for both Ke$ha and Lady Gaga, so I'm being very generous with my comments to both. Neither of them are rockstars, they are popstars. But the OP is not asking who is more of a rockstar, they're asking "who's more natural at rock", in which the answer is Ke$ha. I'm not saying that Gaga can't pull off a rock song, but she's clearly more naturally pop.

Ke$ha grew up on rock music, she loves rock music, and that's where her heart is. She loves making pop music as well, but it's not her natural genre. Being a rockstar or making rock music does not define whether you are more natural at rock. In 2010, rock was not a mainstream successful genre. Still today, it is not. Going down the dance-pop route was the best thing that Ke$ha could have done... it's what gave her a #1 hit in TiK ToK and a #1 album in Animal.

Back to the subject at hand, I'm absolutely convinced that most people who are making comments along the lines of "Lady Gaga, it's not even close" or "There's absolutely nothing rock about Ke$ha", are seriously misinformed, and I'm sure haven't even listened to her album tracks that weren't singles, let alone her unreleased collection. The OP obviously listed her for a reason... Ke$ha loves rock music, has written/recorded rock songs, worked with rock legends and has the attitude of a rockstar.

And it's not just me who thinks this. I have receipts.
http://www.theatlantic.com/entertain...k-star/265811/

So all of you misinformed Monsters can either educate yourselves and continue to say that Gaga is naturally better at rock, while acknowledging that Ke$ha is still pretty darn good at, or take a seat and keep on replaying Sex Dreams while you wait for ARTPOP to leak so that you can download it and pretend to actually support her career.

Zahun

Quote:

Originally posted by SamJJE101

I wouldn't normally say this, but... I'm about to spill the true tea, y'all.

Keep in mind that I'm a stan for both Ke$ha and Lady Gaga, so I'm being very generous with my comments to both. Neither of them are rockstars, they are popstars. But the OP is not asking who is more of a rockstar, they're asking "who's more natural at rock", in which the answer is Ke$ha. I'm not saying that Gaga can't pull off a rock song, but she's clearly more naturally pop.

Ke$ha grew up on rock music, she loves rock music, and that's where her heart is. She loves making pop music as well, but it's not her natural genre. Being a rockstar or making rock music does not define whether you are more natural at rock. In 2010, rock was not a mainstream successful genre. Still today, it is not. Going down the dance-pop route was the best thing that Ke$ha could have done... it's what gave her a #1 hit in TiK ToK and a #1 album in Animal.

Back to the subject at hand, I'm absolutely convinced that most people who are making comments along the lines of "Lady Gaga, it's not even close" or "There's absolutely nothing rock about Ke$ha", are seriously misinformed, and I'm sure haven't even listened to her album tracks that weren't singles, let alone her unreleased collection. The OP obviously listed her for a reason... Ke$ha loves rock music, has written/recorded rock songs, worked with rock legends and has the attitude of a rockstar.

And it's not just me who thinks this. I have receipts.
http://www.theatlantic.com/entertain...k-star/265811/

So all of you misinformed Monsters can either educate yourselves and continue to say that Gaga is naturally better at rock, while acknowledging that Ke$ha is still pretty darn good at, or take a seat and keep on replaying Sex Dreams while you wait for ARTPOP to leak so that you can download it and pretend to actually support her career.

I love u sis