Former teen idols go naughty, who did it best?

Britney

If videos

Slave > Dirrty > WCS

If song

Dirrty > Slave > WCS

"We Can't Stop" had the most successful transition
Although "Dirrty" is the better song

"I'm A Slave 4 U," easily.
"Dirrty" and "We Can't Stop" are both really good, though.

Christina

But Britney is super close.

Slave > Dirrty > WCS

The iconic "I'm A Slave 4 U"

In terms of?

Video: Slave > WCS > Dirty

Song: Dirty > WCS > Slave

Kinda equal overall based on that chart

Going with Dirrty though, cause Song > Video

Dirrty > Slave > WCS

I like all though

Britney > Xtina > Miley, but I love all three songs

Xtina the screaming and grunting alone >>>>> Slave 4 U

I won't talk about the other one. Not worth the WP

What the all have in common is they are each artist's best song by far! For me, 'Dirrty' wins it hands down. Controversial - check. Provocative - check. Overwhelming sex appeal - check. Production before its time - check. Christina's vocals - check. Semi-iconic (well not really but it's still amazing) video - check.

Slave (the song) is actually very underrated imo, it gets you going and feeling sexy, it's flawless.

I'm a Slave 4 U



It made me straight.

You can't compare the iconic I'm A Slave 4 U to semi-iconic Dirry and to not iconic at all We Can't Stop

The iconic I'm A Slave 4 U

Slave 4 U >>>> My favorite Britney single.

Dirrty is flawless as well, and it smashed WW so I don't want to see flopping comments. WCS is an anthem but it's a little early to compare it to these two.

Dirty.....Xtina went WILD.