Do you believe that we are born with a innate talent from birth? Or do you people who are REALLY good at what they do(Michael Jackson, Michael Jordan, Einstein) are obsessed with learning their skills from early age with high motivation?
I personally believe that what people call "talent" are skills that you learn. Not born with it. Einstein said himself that he was not talented, but loved questioning. Michael Jordan worked his a*s of to be the best basketplayer of all time. He showed no early signs of "innate talent". Beyonce couldnt sing well at early age(9-10 years old) if you look at the youtube video where she sings. And look at her now, she is very skilled singer.
I think singing is innate. You either are born with a great voice or not.
Could you explain why because what you are saying then is that singing is not learnable. You are saying that you either can sing or not. Your theory doesnt seem to match with reality.
I think singing is innate. You either are born with a great voice or not.
This, to an extent. People can improve their singing voices over time, but the things that can't be changed (e.g. tone) are what makes a singer great and/or different.
Well yes a lot of it is in your genes so you can be born naturally a better singer than someone else, for example, but a lot of it is in the way you've been brought up and how much you've practised or familiarised yourself with whatever talent you may have
I do believe some have innate talent look at christina she was gifted with this big voice. However if you don't harvest and practice it you stagnate and don't achieve your full potential, hence why xtina has never been a very good vocalist. However that doesn't mean if your not as naturally talented in a particular subject or thing doesn't mean you can never be great at it, just requires you to hustle and work your ass off
I do believe some have innate talent look at christina she was gifted with this big voice. However if you don't harvest and practice it you stagnate and don't achieve your full potential, hence why xtina has never been a very good vocalist. However that doesn't mean if your not as naturally talented in a particular subject or thing doesn't mean you can never be great at it, just requires you to hustle and work your ass off
I wouldnt say she was "gifted" with a big voice. Its just that we all have diffrent voices, but yes.
In the video you can see Christina singing with basic singing skills when she was 9 years old, she didnt seem to be a great singer at all to me. That does not scream "innate talent" to me. It seems to me that she has aquired some basic singing skills that she had learned at an early age. Neither does Beyonces performance screaming "she is gifted" when she was at the age of 8. It seems to me that they showed an early intrest in singing and learned singing for many years.
People have diffrent voice and people like diffrent voices. That is unique to every human being, but I dont believe that you are born with a skill.
