I needs a banner y'all! Get to cracking.

So, yeah, any song that failed to chart in the top 40 (US) or top 20 (UK) is eligible. ANY SONG - unless it charted at say, #29 in the UK but #2 in the US. Then, the bigger country trumps it.

Just don't include more than two songs by any one artist. Have fun with it!

Send me a pm of your top 20 choices by August 10th.

FYC:

How is this not more active? I WILL participate fully

Is this eligible?

Hey Janet!!!

Not Myself Tonight for #1

Of course!

But just so lambs now - songs like Butterfly and The Roof are NOT eligible because they were never released as physical singles, thereby making them ineligible to chart on the Hot 100 at the time. Same for Forever, etc.

#29 peak. But you tried!

Not Myself Tonight was a hit in both charts, going top 40 on the Hot 100, and top 20 in the UK.

Every song by Legend X was a hit somewhere.

then I guess Ill have to go for WooHoo or You Lost Me

but sis what are the sales of NMT

Or, you know, Dirrty. Went to number one in the UK, but only made 47 here. As I said before, bigger country trumps smaller.

Do Hip-Hop and R&B songs count?

Kylie should slay

Still upset over that tbh, deserved to do so much better

Well, not really? Come Into My World and Slow are the only songs that qualify; everything else either went top 40 or didn't chart.

Question: What if a song was given a physical release in the UK and didn't chart within the top 20, but wasn't eligible for chart placement on the Hot 100 b/c it wasn't given a commercial release?

Is that song eligible for this?

Oh, I thought songs like All the Lovers, which was actually released but still failed to chart, would count.

Nvm then

I love this idea SO much! I don't know how I'm even going to make a list. There are too many flops to even keep track of and so many of them are great.