Shes a great vocalist and musician, which Xtina is great in.

Freaky with her performance and videos, which is Britney's department.

Shes very glitz and glam with her fashion and her presence which feeds her gay fans and its of the key things Beyonce really great at.

Once Gaga came to the scene these three ex-trinty had a low points in their career.

Do you think Gaga is those three combined and thats what made their stans/fans become monsters ?

Discuss.

Despite the ADD stanning here at atrl, it IS completely possible to appreciate more than one artist at a time.

She stole half of Britney/Madonna's audience, as evidenced by their dwindling tour numbers

I am still a Britney Stan but she nearly made me a little monster during the fame/monster era

It's easier to ask where Monsters came from. I'll start.

I was a huge fan of Beyonce (still am), but never really listened to the top 40. House/Electro was my genre before Gaga.

You'll probably give up when ARTPOP come out and slay the Universe

I knew your answer before you even posted, i saw your name in the members

Thank God i'm not a lil monster.

Well that's nice I guess

How does this answer the question?

-

No, I agree with what Edge said

Maybe Britney and Xtina because she fulfiled the blonde-popstar role (not that there always must be these roles) but Beyonce makes a completely different type of music and even their glitz and glam similarities are very different.

I think she created a lot of hybrid stans, and maybe stole and completely converted a lot of Brit/Madonna fans as she's white, blonde, very pop and very gay.

I think with Bey, Telephone obviously made our stanbases get along and in turn resulted in a lot of us appreciating and learning more about her, therefore becoming a fan/stan of her

Why ?

Probably, but she has returned them all after the Born This Way era.

You mean the same fans that went running for the hills when Born This Way came out...or better yet Marry The Night?

Those arent the type of fans anyone needs. Her base is fickle as ****

No such thing as stealing other stans.