My lord....

Some atrl members are just really disgusting.

Xtina actually spearheaded the 3 trends stated by the op. Britney, Stefani, and Adele constantly following the leader.

X was bigger in size when Moves Like Jagger came out, and became the biggest collaboration of all time which was a bigger single than anything Adele ever, and will ever release.

the pressure on some people. Take it easy guys.

You don't say

http://kworb.net/ww/wwtotals.html

"At this point we can agree that the Telecommunications Act of 1996 ruined not only radio, but the record business. The key to selling records is exposure. And once all the stations consolidated, became homogeneous, the public tuned out, there was no consensus.

The consensus has evaded satellite radio. Even Howard Stern speaks to a fraction of the faithful. So, despite satellite’s strengths, it’s not an aggregator, it’s not a central marketplace, where you can drop in and check out what people are into, get a taste of what’s going on almost instantly.

Of course you could listen to Top Forty radio, but it hasn’t been classic Top Forty, the best of the best, in over a decade. So the fan has been flummoxed.

But as bad as radio is, why do all the cool acts come from the U.K? Why, when you listen to a U.K. act do you get excited, feel that inner pulse, and the American acts leave you feeling "been there, done that"?

I got a number of e-mails complaining that Duffy is too close to Amy Winehouse. That both are reminiscent of an era gone by. But do you remember the ska revolution of the early eighties? There were great tracks by the (English) Beat, the Specials, Selecter… There was a vibrancy to the music, and it wasn’t just a clone of the earlier Jamaican sound… I’ve never heard a sixties ska record that sounded like "Mirror In The Bathroom". Even if one concedes that Duffy and Amy Winehouse are cut from the same cloth, that sound is new to so much of the audience, and is not a direct rip of what came before. The fact that there are insiders pooh-poohing them makes me feel good. This is the passion we used to have in the U.S., before everybody started playing video games.

Furthermore, the vaunted records in the U.S. are always indie rock. Thin, alternative stuff made by geeks who never had a date about fantasies they’re having in their bedrooms. Intellectually, one might be able to relate, but there’s a lack of sex, an absence of a visceral quality, that revs one up and gets one excited.

That’s what’s off the grid. What’s on the grid is disposable. Rap has become a laugh. And the popsters are all molded by old men, with their sexuality drained as they sing the concoctions of professional songwriters. You just can’t get excited about music in the U.S. But in the U.K., you can feel the heat, you’re involved. It’s a national pastime, following hit records (instead of the grosses of high concept movies!)

I was inundated with e-mail about this act Adele. At first listen I loved her, then when I downloaded all the tracks I realized that she was just a bit too jazzy for me. But I applaud where she’s coming from. But although she’s a smash in the U.K., I seriously doubt she can make it big here in America. Because she’s FAT!

Yes, you can be a drug addict. You can be stupid. But don’t be FAT! In America it’s all about appearances. Fat girls don’t get a chance. Hell, the girl on "Ugly Betty" isn’t even ugly!

But when was the last time you SAW a record. Oh, that’s right, MTV made music a visual medium. Well, it’s NOT! Music is something you hear, check Adele out through your ears. Then maybe watch some video footage. Because it will be a shock. We never see ANYTHING like this on television in America.

Sure, some of the U.K. acts don’t travel, you’ve got to be British to understand them. And some are flashes in the pan. But so many are frozen out of our system, there’s just no way for them to enter, to get traction. And that’s a comment on us, not them. While U.K. residents are scheming up innovative tunes, in America kids are playing "Guitar Hero", or learning dance steps and getting plastic surgery to win on "American Idol" or get on Top Forty radio.

At least on "Guitar Hero" they’re playing great music. That’s the draw. There hasn’t been great music on the radio in the U.S. for far too long. And I don’t see Clear Channel and its brethren taking chances any time soon.

It’s our culture, stupid. We don’t revere great music, we revere fame. Our national radio station is TMZ.com. We don’t want to listen to Britney’s music (which hasn’t been great since the very first hit), we just want to watch the train-wreck. Beyonce is beautiful and talented, but her material is not memorable. We don’t foster creativity over here. For a renegade country, we do our best to give renegades no chance.

Ahmet Ertegun said a hit record is something you hear on the radio while lying in bed in your pajamas that makes you get up, get dressed and go to the all night record store to buy. When was the last time you heard a record like that on U.S. radio? When was the last time you LISTENED to U.S. radio? Radio’s all about business. Music is all about money. Isn’t that the number one complaint of musicians today? How do I get paid?

Stop worrying about getting paid and start worrying about making music unfiltered by the system, that grabs people, and makes them want to hear it again and again. Maybe, if you do, we can get people excited about music. When "Rolling Stone" features starlets and is loaded with car ads you know the air has gone out of the balloon. And the Web isn’t much better. Like I said, listen to those indie alternative records championed on Pitchfork. The big players ignore the Websites and the Websites like being so far off the grid that most people ignore them. Can’t we fight it out in the center, like in the U.K? Can’t we all be focused on greatness in one pool? Can’t we try to MAKE some cream, never mind have it rise to the top?"

Great article, rbautz.

The new classic went #1 in more charts than anything Adele ever released. iTunes' positions right now won't change that. Christina even blocked Adele's Someone Like You (1 of her biggest hits) on the Pop radio.

Not you completely disregarding RITD
Anyways, Adele's success wasn't a result of her being bigger. She was popular because of the music.

The wide appeal of her music and the variations of genres helped her a lot. She also has a likeable personality. So easy to channel the people. Her lyrics bring general messages.

Well damn.

What I want to say is, with Adele you are in another dimension, RITD or SLY are instant classic hits who sells today twice or triple than MLJ..

As big as MLJ was it will be most likely forgotten at some degree, not so RITD in the US or SLY in Europe she created something like Billie Jean, Smells Like Teen Spirit or the great Withney/Parton hit.

And don't forget the big Album sales at the same time, it was her biggest competition to her singles.

I don't say they are the best hits ever, but her hits were in the best global enviroment, you heard it on radio and you could see it at the same time on YT in many different perfect performances live.

Are Christina fans still pretending that MLJ is a Christina song? She's featured there, and she only sings like 10 seconds of the song.

Because her size had nothing to do with her success.

Exactly! Her relatable lyrics are a big part of what gives her such a wide appeal..exactly what I'm trying to say in another thread.

PS I love your avi