YES YES YES!!!!

yes

LOL if Hilary Turns to be the X Factor Judge

I mean Simon you could do better than that!!!
When is the forst audittion??

It'd be great if this is true

Omg yes!

Mess Poor show.

OMG YEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEES KSFDOSDFIVODJKIVDJRTIFG

She ain't gonna bring viewers. She's been gone for quite some time. The GP seems not to care 'bout her anymore.

True, but maybe we'll be proven wrong.. I mean look what happened with Britney.. Everyone care about her but she wasn't a good judge.. (to say the least)

People dissing her because she's not relevant enough are completely missing the point of what Simon is trying to do. Last season proved a big name is no longer what draws in viewers - as did American Idol.

asdnasndoausnd I hope it's true

TMZ just reported Kelly and Paulina joining, though.

If anything, the new judges made American Idol go downhill.

I still don't think Hilary is a good choice because people won't take this show seriously anymore, I mean its not like they took it seriously before but 2 ex Disney stars? come on Simon.

Who?!

I hope it's not her tho (hilary) she's been out of the music scene for so long

Kelly rule the panel?

Obviously you didn't watch her on the UK X-Factor

YEEEEES, please, my queen

This would be a GREAT comeback for her.