Out of those names, I'd want a Simon/Demi/Kelly/Faith panel.

Don't do it Simon!!!

I wouldn't mind seeing Hil there, she was one of my faves back in the day.

Faith Hill would be better considering it is a singing competition and Faith is a better singer than Hilary. I like both though.

omggg
https://twitter.com/HilaryDuff/statu...58842711818240

I like Kelly, but I would love to see Hilary and Faith on it. It would be really great and that may inspire Duff to get into a studio and start recording something. I don't think Paulina Rubio will be a good judge, plus she has already been on a version of The Voice. Jennifer Love Hewitt will be great as well, if Hill does not make it, it could be Hilary, Demi, Jennifer and Simon. It seems like I will be watching The X Factor again since I dropped it once I saw robot Britney.

I'd love a Simon | Demi | Ne-Yo | Hilary.

Faith Hill would be a GREAT choice and I could see her really taking the show seriously and trying to nurture her acts.

WAITTTT

I lived for Hilary back in the day. Please be true

No offense to Hilary, but it makes ZERO sense to her and Demi on the same panel, Simon is not that dumb.

Faith Hill would be a great addition, though.

I loved Hilary back in the day but they need a respected singer on the panel. I feel like part of the reason for X Factor's lackluster performance last last season is because the audience didn't have enough respect for Demi because of her age and Britney for of various reasons.

And then having 3 women on the panel is not giving the core audience (females) any eye candy.

Simon/Demi/Faith/Ne-Yo or another young male singer would work. Hilary or Jennifer Love Hewitt could co-host with Mario.

The truth is no matter who they put as a judge. These singing shows are a fad now. They don't really make anyone a star. All they are doing is losing ratings because they are generic and obvious.

Has the voice had a succesful winner? Umm no... what about X-Factor? Last years winner is nowhere to be heard. American Idol is going down the sink too. They havent had a succesful winner in a long time. They need to stop or change some things

WTF?

Hilary Duff is primarily known and celebrated as an ACTRESS - an an incredibly talented one at that.


Since when has she made such a considerable contribution to MUSIC that she should be JUDGING and MENTORING upcoming musical talent?

Will Be Great!

Dear god. Simon is trying to kill off his own show. He must have something new he wants to start.

The show was killed from the moment it started, let's not even go there.