Yes, im here 4 this

I wish...

Hopefully not. How is she gon' give the contestants advices about improving their vocals, etc?

I would love Hilary on the show. Used to be a fan until she stopped working.

I didn't report this because it's not even harsh BUT that doesn't even matter, look at the judges from American Idol: Jennifer Lopez, Ellen, and Nicki Minaj. Hell Britney was a judge on the X-Factor and we know how much the media and ATRL loves to criticize her vocals, the show is more than just vocals so that shouldn't even be a factor in the mix.

I love both Demi and Hilary, and hilary needs this so I think she should. This could be why she was in Lodnon...

At first I wasn't that keen on the idea but now I'm hoping she does it!

This excuse is really stale since there were already 2 non-singers judges on the panel (Simon and L.A. Reid).