I'll pick a random popular song out right now or in the past and put it up against Gimme More. We'll then see how truely good Britney's comeback is compared to "other hits" out right now.
Eighth Battle
Gimme More vs. Ain't No Other Man
Gimme More %'s of wins! -> 57% <-
Whine Up vs. Gimme More / 20 vs. 8
Gimme More vs. A Public Affair / 25 to 20
Gimme More vs. Girlfriend / 20 to 15
Gimme More vs. The Sweet Escape (GS&A) / 18 vs. 16
Sexyback vs. Gimme More / 22 vs. 17
Beautiful Liar vs. Gimme More / 18 vs. 17
Gimme More vs. Shut Up And Drive / 23 vs. 15
I actually thought that would win, since everyone loves Rihanna. And Umbrella is the song of the year, like Say it Right. It's too early to put those two songs against Gimme More. I'm doing the 2nd best options that are just "hits"