This. Rihanna is my fave, but Janet is a legend. This is a dumb question to even ask.

Rihanna already has more memorable songs though. Ergo, RIhanna > Nipple.

This is an insult to common music knowledge Janet by miles. Rihanna has not come even remotely close to Janet.

Um, how do you know this? Rihanna's songs are much newer, time will tell if they are more "memorable"

Is this a joke? Janet alone has outsold pretty much Rihanna's entire album discography, and Janet was pre-digital era, so of course Rihanna is going to outsell her with singles.

Janet is clearly more successful.

No song of Rihanna's is memorable. To this day, WFL is already forgotten.

Miss You Much, WHYDFML, Together Again, TTWLG, and many other hits from Janet are classics, unlike Rihanna's entire discography.

Because kids 15 and under cant name 5 off the top of their head. And its not because of her being "old" because they all know Michael, Mariah, Whitney, Madonna, Stevie Wonder etc. Or else do you want to agree that Janet aint in their league.

I couldn't name over 5 Mariah, Whitney and Stevie songs when i was 15. I had to start listening to them just as i did Janet.

I was referring to an average 15 year old.

Doing the most as usual.

I doubt any of my friends could have named them either? It all depends what music your parents like and who's music they bring you up with. Unless you have a demographic receipt of this, this argument won't go far.

Mariah Carey

Hero
Vision of Love
We Belong Together
Always Be My Baby
One Sweet Day.


If you were born in the 90s - late 00s you know this song.

Whitney
I Wanna Dance With Somebody
Greatest Love Of All
I Will Always Love You
How Will I Know?
Saving All My Love For You


Everybody knows these songs.


Stevie Wonder might be a stretch but Im gonna say he still has a more memorable discography than Damita.

Janet

Its not even about sells...theirs no question who's more successful its Janet Jackson.. its about the talent, The "ART" of music...not who can drop a bunch of little "Quick singles" They burn out...Drop another quick single it burns out...Janet jackson understood the essence of music....Anoyone can hop in the studio..Gather up the hottest producers... And Get a hit.......

what a pointless thread. any non delusional person knows the anwser

Janet by miles. She had 5 back to back SMASH eras she is a LEGEND. I'm listening to her right now actually I love her

Girl your grammar...

But anyways Beyonce is working with half of Rihanna's hit making team and I'll be sure to bookmark this post and laugh at you when she fails to attain a top 10 hit for the second era in a row.

The Talent, The Art? Girl you have no idea what you're talking about, Janet is no one's amazing singer and neither is Rihanna but they have the diction and the tone that the people want to hear. Don't try to use Janet as a scapegoat for your petty shade.

The OP says "More Successful Janet or Rihanna", so it is about sales and accolades. Learn how to read and write.



Their, There, They're. <--- Unless English is not your first language there is no excuse for mixing these up.