When was this manly cute guy called out?

Voted for my two girls, Angie and Kree


Although I thought Kree went 2nd so I accidentally voted for Janelle twice

Just watched the 2nd half of the show on my DVR, and Amber DID THAT with that second performance. I understand how it may be too slow for some, but vocally she was superb, elegant, and very controlled.

It's sad to say but Amber will be leaving soon...AI is all about ratings...they're not gonna have two black girls for that long...i dont even think theres ever been two black ppl in an AI finale...america wouldn't even watch..sad but true

studio tracks:

Throw all your support and votes towards Kree for me!

All 50 of my votes went to Angie. She was flawless tonight. You guys were WAY too harsh on her I'll Stand By You performance. Ya'll are acting like she was the one who set off the bombs, or acting like she was that mystery man on the rooftop of that building next to explosion. I mean

I'll Stand By You was like one of the best of the night, only behind Halo and When You Believe.

I can't believe this **** isn't online yet. I'm gonna cry

MLD, you never fail to come up with the most analogies.

Too soon, man.

The next theme is gonna be one hit wonders! Ready for the messy performances next week!

Youtube has it. Goto the American Idol channel.

Watching now!!!
Nicki looks drop-dead gorgeous! Mariah does too! I'm so excited for tonight! I am sure these 5 ladies will bring it! I'm so looking forward to Mariah's comments and flawlessness today! I'm in love with her

-Candice: I think the arrangement was genius! I do have to say this wasn't the best song choice for Candice, the song just went on and on and on. After last week i had HUGE expectations! Her vocals were flawless as always and she looked STUNNING! It just wasn't #POW. But yeah, good job. Ummm... now that i heard the comments, i feel like they over-praised her. If Jannelle gave this performance we wouldn't be getting these comments.

-Jannelle: i love this girl. She has the best personality in the world. I feel like she connects the most to the songs every week i just feel every single word she sings and i see it in her eyes that she believes what she's singing. Weren't her best vocals yet they were still outstanding thanks to what i just said. One of her best performances! I hate that she's so underrated! I love her!!! I like her so much better than Kree cuz i can feel her

Nicki is bringing it tonight! She's so put together and right on spot with her comments <3 Keith is full of ****! I felt every word! And the song was full of emotion!

-Kree: First time i hear her kind of struggling to hit the high notes. I love her awag on stage! The way she moves is just really... cool. Still, i receive 0 emotion from her. I tend to look into the person's eye and she just gives me the same expression the whole time. She sounded good tho so that's what matters.

See how Keith is so understanding of whatever the situation was with the cameras and stuff and then with the other contestants he just isn't like that. It's sooooooooo clear that his fav is Kree and he always praises her even if it isn't her best. It gets annoying at times
OMG YASSSSSSSSSSSS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! NICKI AND MARIAH TALKED TO EACH OTHER I'M LIVING!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

- Angie: Didn't like her performance and i also think these have been her worst vocals yet. I'm shocked they gave her a standing ovation. I'm really gonna need her to step it up for the next round. I feel like i heard a different thing lol and i STAN for Angie. I'm so rewatching this at the end of the show.

-Amber: THE VOCALS! My god!!! I felt like when she first started singing "Can't live" it was sort of anti-climatic since the tone was SO LOW but she did a nice job overall. The high notes were life. And i also really loved her runs in the beginning so i disagree with Onika.

YASSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSS NICKI PRAISING MARIAH OMFG WHAT IS LIFE I WANT THEM TO GET ALONG THEY'RE TWO BOSS BITCHES! OMG THIS IS SO EXCITING!

-Candice: there's a certain rawness in her voice that i just adore. I wish she would have held that note when the key-change came but still holy ****! i got chills again! Candice did it again! She constantly gives me chills ugh! This i was just insanely flawless omg. Queen is back. I will ***** this performance the whole week just like i did with "Love Song". Still have chills all over my body.

YASSSSSSSSSSSS NICKI KEEPS PRAISING OMFG!!! I'M HAVING A BREAKDOWN RN!!!

-Jannelle: THIS IS HOW YOU ****ING OWN A STAGE! This is EXACTLY how a country singer should sound. Perfect song choice! She's ready to get her record deal and go on a successful tour and slay the country chart!

They're absolutely picking on this girl. She gave amazing vocals and her performance was FLAWLESS. I ****ing hate Randy and i hate them all for criticizing her vocals. Keith picking on her again UGH! I'm so mad and pressed rn.

-Kree: praise her for that unexpected song-choice. This girl is so STUNNING! omg<3 this was a different side of Kree that i've never seen before and i ****ing love it. This is the first time i actually felt her performance! I loved it! Her best performance to date.

Nicki is absolutely right. Kree just prooved that she might actually be even better on a different genre than Country judging from this performance.

-Angie: YASSSSSSSSSS!!! Angie is freaking back!!! She murdered that ****! She never showcased that range before holy ****! Started off pitchy like the first second but this really got epic after. I'm happy she redeemed herself this time around.

-Amber: so classy, so elegant! This girl can sing her behing off and she has proven that every week. As they said, i really do hope America gets it right this time around.



At this point, they're almost equally good to me. I have a feeling Jannelle will be leaving today. This is impossible! I couldn't pick! I would give 10 votes to each girl. I feel like Amber and Candice were clearly the winners of the night for me though. Angie, Jannelle and Kree were on the same level in my eyes.

Amber is overrated