Poll: Gaga vs. Rihanna - Page 4

Bright

Quote:

Originally posted by Sinvius

Let's be realistic, Rihanna did have a small amount of impact on the pop culture world. It is something.

The obvious answer is Lady Gaga, she has had more impact than Rihanna will probably have until the end of her career. Rihanna has good music, that's basically it.

But we're talking bout the influence in Pop Music right now nd not who had more impact in Pop clothing or smthin like that

OriginalQueen

The queen of pop rihanna

CannibalMonster

Quote:

Originally posted by OriginalQueen

The queen of pop rihanna

Now sis, let's not go that far.

♚ PRiNCE HiGH ♚

Quote:

Originally posted by Sinvius

Let's be realistic, Rihanna did have a small amount of impact on the pop culture world. It is something.

The obvious answer is Lady Gaga, she has had more impact than Rihanna will probably have until the end of her career. Rihanna has good music, that's basically it.

/endthread.

Scuba_Dive

Visually: Gaga
Musically: Gaga

SaneBeyhannaStan

I think people admire Gaga's huge musical success and that she tries to go way off script.

However, I've heard more songs styled similarly to Rihanna's, and have heard some cite her as inspiration.

SaneBeyhannaStan

I always hear people say Gaga has had huge impact but can someone tell me what her impact is linked to, are we talking impact on the sound of pop music?

Are we talking impact on other artist?

Idgi

toanythingtaboo

Quote:

Originally posted by SaneBeyhannaStan

I always hear people say Gaga has had huge impact but can someone tell me what her impact is linked to, are we talking impact on the sound of pop music?

Are we talking impact on other artist?

Idgi

Did you miss the whole dance/pop explosion in 2009/10 and the sudden influx of RedOne tracks?

Gaga played a HUGE part in that.

Honey

Rihanna.

Rama

Let me just quote Rolling Stone Magazine...

Quote:

Gaga may, on occasion, draw heavily from the music and iconography of her heroes, but her influence on her own peers is even more obvious: Miley Cyrus and Christina Aguilera practically destroyed their careers trying to copy her; Rihanna and Katy Perry keep getting weirder (see Perry's "E.T." video); Ke$ha is allowed to be famous.

Now I leave.

HausOfYax

well .... THE QUEEN GAGA.

FreeAsMyWeave

Cannabis

Quote:

‘If Katy sticks with being Katy, and Ke$ha is Ke$ha, and Rihanna is Rihanna, and I'm me, there's room for everybody. The problem is when people look at Gaga and say, "Oh, that works; I'm going to be like that."’

- Miley Cyrus, January 2013

Cannabis

From this Week:

Rihanna is not even an option

jokermusic

Quote:

Originally posted by Cannabis

From this Week:

Rihanna is not even an option

Well no minorities are other than Obama so I don't think their focused on the whole public,

also I don't give a **** what anyone says, rihanna had major impact especially in 2007 when every black singer began having short haircuts....not that they didnt already exist but we all know every black singer had beyonce weave, after rih, Ciara,Monica,Chriette Michelle, Keri hilson, etc all wanted to try something new .......after her pop hits everyone went pop including beyonce, even kanye said that.....gaga had success because gggb made radio more accepting of dance music again....cause it was all hip hop/ urban and pop rock before. Also don't u guys remember how ****** fashion in music was pre rihanna 2007, after that everyone wanted to say fashion is so important.....gaga made impact in taking what rihanna was trying to start and doing it better, and also just adding the artistry to pop music and crazy fashion to mainstream but when do u listen to the radio and say " oh she sounds like a gaga wannabe" you don't but everyone is quick to say she sounds like rih or looks like a rih clone.

K$Animal

Rihanna and it's not even close

jackieshann

gagz and it's not even close

Nippy'sReceipts

Quote:

Originally posted by B2R4D

Visually: Gaga
Musically: Rihanna

This.

Scuba_Dive

Barack Obama vs Lady Gaga

Seems about right

Befour

I'll let the good sis Rolling Stone answer for me:

Quote:

Gaga's debut was a game-charger, making dark, booming dance-pop—buoyed by the almighty four-on-the-floor thump of Eurodisco—the dominant sound of the global charts. And it introduced the world to an outrageously plus-sized form of pop divadom—to a provocateur and fashion plate who treated the whole world as her red carpet. Those paparazzi she sang about weren't just metaphorical, after all.