We ARE discussing about Born This Way vs. I Kissed A Girl tho.

I love both songs but lets not ignore the receipts.

The rock version of ''I Kissed a Girl'' is...

I Kissed a Girl
#150 Greece
#193 Luxembourg
#197 Dominican Republic
#205 Portugal
#266 Finland

Born This Way
#113 Argentina
#173 Costa Rica
#195 Luxembourg
#215 Peru
#221 Lithuania
#231 Greece
#252 Thailand
#270 Hong Kong
#271 Portugal
#271 United Arab Emirates
#275 Finland
#280 El Salvador
#289 Chile
#295 Bahrain
#303 Colombia
#331 Japan
#332 Israel
#339 Singapore
#352 Venezuela



yet Gaga got more headlines, made more coins and had her second $100m+ grossing tour in 2012

Katy can remain selling her cute discounted singles

Born This Way >>>>>>>

I can't at the fact haters saying BTW is forgotten and nobody remembers it when they are the ones who come running to these threads

IKAG has something BTW does NOT have which is impact.
Sorry but Gaga lost this one BIG time

(Massive) I Kissed a Girl

Madonna with 5 positions

the BTW announcement at VMAs made a bigger impact than anything Katy has ever done

Born This Way was a bigger hit, but I prefer IKAG.

Though I love IKAG more, it doesn't have impact either.
IKAG is just another avererage, generic pop song
BTW is just another insecure-teenage anthem for the closet gays; the gay remix of JTWYA

next

Come on now.
Are you really denying that IKAG had more impact than BTW?
Even people who don't listen to pop music at all know IKAG.
The line: 'I kissed a girl and I liked it' is more memorable than BTW's lyrics, video, everything. The iconic IKAG wins. Period.

And why was that?
Because of her meat dress.

Please, the legacy of BTW already faded 2 months after its release.

But IKAG was released 3 years before BTW, and it's still outselling BTW in bigger markets (Greece, Portugal and Finland).

Not you clocking yourself

Obviously IKAG was a bigger hit!

What is this Avril fan doing instigating stan wars for? Give it up.

The legendary I Kissed A Girl which had real impact.

Born This Way, obviously.

The Queens on this site can drag Born This Way all they want to, but at the end of the day it was a legendary single release and isn't going to be forgotten.


I kissed a Girl is just that cute pop song that you enjoyed jamming out to on a Friday night a few years back.

:shrug: