Not her biggest hit, but it would have been big, especially in Europe.

No, if MTN couldn't become a hit, then Scheiße neither.

It wouldn't be has big as Poker Face or Bad Romance, but I'm sure that it would be a big hit on the Born This Way era

Wold have flopped worse than Marry The Night.

It would have been as successful as Judas tbh

The Edge of Glory was #3 on the Hot 100, sold 5 million copies worldwide, and was Gaga's biggest radio hit to date. Don't let the fumes cloud you, dear.

While I live for that BOP, I think it would have been a tough sell, especially at a point where Gaga already was struggling.

I also love MTN and look how that song did.

Nah

YES

The era was doomed to fail anyway, too much poor management. Although, this definitely would have had potential to smash if the timing was right and they made a radio mix.

You & I and Marry The Night should not have happened. Scheisse would've been a massive hit, definitely. Not her biggest but one of the biggest, possibly the biggest hit from BTW.

It definitely would have smashed.

I doubt it would have been her biggest hit. Still like it, though.