What do you think? It definitely is radio friendly and also very catchy. I think Interscope just thought it wouldn't stick because of the foreign aspect to the song (which isn't even real)... The RedOne production is very hit-worthy. He has had a lot of hit's for Gaga, Nicki Minaj, and others.

Scheiße is also one of the top played audio video's on Gaga's VEVO youtube page with 7.5 million views.

I don't think Scheiße would've been a bigger hit than Poker Face or Bad Romance but I think it would be up there in a lower tier with Alejandro, Paparazzi, and Telephone.

I'll never get over Scheiße not being a single.

It would be a summer smash hit.

I feel like it would be known as a gaga classic.

Yes, +Lovegame

Scheiße not being a single stings more than Dance In the Dark not being a single.

You can tell Gaga cares so much about this song.

Biggest? Probably not. It's going to be really hard for her to ever top Poker Face and Bad Romance, they were mammoth hits.

But I think with a radio edit to cut the intro down it could have been a hit. I have some friends who don't really love any Gaga song except Schiebe.

Love Scheiße but I never 100% agreed it should've been a single. I don't think the GP would be here for a song that's half in fake German (I mean, sure Gaga is known for her rah-rahs but this one is downright gibberish) and it's just a little too weird in general.

It could have been the next 'Single Ladies (Put A Ring On It)'.

Feminist anthem.

Not biggest but I can see it peaking higher than MTN and Judas

Sheisse would have been PERFECT if it was released after Judas. I'm pissed she didn't take advantage of the summer and release that, along with Americano.

It would've been HUGE, not her biggest probably but certainly huge. I wish GaGa and her management wouldn't have let MTN flopping mean an end to the era, there was a lot left to be released (Scheisse, Hair, Americano, etc).

Americano, regardless of how like 98% of the Gaga stan base hates this song, could've been a good single as well. If I'm not mistaken, it's the best-selling non-single from Born This Way on iTunes. It also got a small amount of promo from the Puss n' Boots movie and Glee covered it.

she really missed the ball by not releasing that track. It would have been a huge hit, it has a very catchy hook, and would've been a better choice than Marry The Night.

I was fine with them cutting it off after MTN. If the first or second single flops that hard, then sure you should keep trying, but when you're on your fifth single in an era that already had some bad spots (Express Yourself crap, Judas etc.) I think it's appropriate to let it die with a little dignity. Every successive flop means less immediate support for the next single, so a 6th or 7th single might've just been overkill.

Ideally the single releases would've just been planned better to avoid this issue (especially NO Judas).

Would've been giant!

People instantly noticed the similarities with 'Bad Romance'. Poor decision. Without the similar parts and more original work 'Judas' could have been huge.