I was talking about those things as a collective entity, which is something Katy Perry owns. She utilised the "Candyfornia" imagery and it's recognisable within popular culture. Provide some adequate of examples for Rihanna which are put together in a similar fashion, and then perhaps I will be inclined to change my mind.

No. I honestly can't remember any videos from Rihanna other than Umbrella.

If WFL isn't iconic, neither is CG.

The poll is at Queen's side what a lead lol... Please cats don't try this again.

That's cute and all, but a naive comparison between 2 POP videos from 2 POP stars is not enough for it to be considered iconic, it's not like everyone's 100% original, and some of those things are reaches, like ''Standing on restaurant tables'' ok...?

Look I'm not saying it's a bad video or anything, it's just that the song built this huge hype surrounding the release of the video and some you stans now think is this complete and flawless original masterpiece, when it's actually a pop video, nothing more, nothing less.

That is correct.

Since when is CG iconic? in that case we might as well say Pon de Replay is more iconic.

The OP is such an attention seeking *****.

CG and WFL are not Iconic, but CG is way better and actually better than any Rihanna video ... I like them both but CG may not be Iconc, but It is more Iconic than Umbrella and WFL... I actually enjoy Katy's videos more than Riri but Katy's last videos are horrible - Part Of Me+Wide Awake <<<< Thinking of You<Hot N Cold=E.T.=Firework<CG