Poll: Stronger discography: Janet or Mariah? - Page 5

Praise Mariallah

Quote:

Originally posted by Early_Mornin

LOL! No it isn't.

Oop my bad. I mean't the Rock & Roll Hall of Fame, not a RS list.

To coincide with the 2007 Induction ceremony, the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame released their list of the Definitive 200 Albums that every music lover should own, celebrating classic recordings by favorite iconic and contemporary artists.

MCBeth

Quote:

Originally posted by Early_Mornin

Music isn't all about the voice ya know.

Where exactly did I say it was?

I invite you to take a look at my sig.

Quote:

Originally posted by madonnas

They were the ones that brought up acclaim I think critics matter but they shouldn't dictate taste.

I was just saying in general, I don't think you could be any more obvious in your preference in "critics"

I noticed that off the bat about you.

There is nothing wrong with that, I've just never looked at critics, I don't feel the need to, I'm listening to the music for myself not for what others think is the best. They are biased individuals to what they like and I'm not here for that.

critics

MCBeth

Quote:

Originally posted by madonnas

I think you're misunderstanding what I was saying

I was asking someone who was saying/acting like it was some obvious fact that Mimi > Janet to explain themselves, they did, that's it

I'm not misunderstanding anything at all, I understand that you want them to explain why they think Mariah >>> Janet.

I don't think you understood what I was saying! You want them to explain their reasoning because you feel the correct answer should be Janet but like I said before and I'll say it again, IT IS UP TO THE INDIVIDUAL WHICH DISCOGRAPHY THEY LIKE BETTER.

I mean to quote you:

Quote:

I actually really prefer the mixtapes to E-mc2

Did I ask you to explain that when I CLEARLY don't agree? No, because it is YOUR preference

Japoy

Mariah Carey, of course.

madonnas

Quote:

Originally posted by MCBeth

I'm not misunderstanding anything at all, I understand that you want them to explain why they think Mariah >>> Janet.

I don't think you understood what I was saying! You want them to explain their reasoning because you feel the correct answer should be Janet but like I said before and I'll say it again, IT IS UP TO THE INDIVIDUAL WHICH DISCOGRAPHY THEY LIKE BETTER.

I mean to quote you:

Did I ask you to explain that when I CLEARLY don't agree? No, because it is YOUR preference

I know it's my preference, but I wasn't going around this thread acting like Janet > Mimi is an objective fact

Gangsta4alife

Quote:

Originally posted by TheAqua

It's nothing wrong with liking Janet's.earlier I was just messing with folks.

Though If you must know why I am inclined to side with Mimi,read below
V
V

No this WHOLE thing is about who has the better discography OVERALL,and I chose Mariah Carey. It is clear that she is more consistent and has been more versatile throughout the years regarding her sound,work ethic and artistry.

Meanwhile Janet only has like two AWESOME albums

For me personally it's about consistency and having a well rounded body of work,which Mariah does,and Janet does NOT.

More versatile now that's a lie. Anyways Janet all the way:

I can't really get into Mariah like that and I must be the only one that can't stand her debut album, the emancipation etc.......

MCBeth

Quote:

Originally posted by madonnas

I know it's my preference, but I wasn't going around this thread acting like Janet > Mimi is an objective fact

No, you'd rather Mixtapes >>>>> E=MC^2

I know it's her worst album but ch......the mixtapes! That's a new low

ECNEICSNOC

Yall did way too much on the discographies of the queens. The delusuon

MCBeth

Quote:

Originally posted by ECNEICSNOC

Yall did way too much on the discographies of the queens. The delusuon

I know, they just can't deal with the way the Queens slay their lives, they can't deal

Pecinta Mariah

are you asking for the preference? if so, definitely Mariah but Janet has some good bop tho

atrlster

Janet winning

I thought people really disliked her music here

Romaysae

Mariah

AndresVanDeKamp

The fact I can only get into Damnita Jo, Velvet Rope, and 20 YO as full albums, says a LOT about Janet's music.

There are very few songs in Mariah's discography that I dislike.

Schhh

Mariah. Daydream and Music Box are one of my favorite albums of all time.

Smooth Criminal

Mariah. It's more consistent, undeniably.

dcode78

Janet.