Originally posted by FOCK

Gaga may be a great vocalist, but she has never stepped out of any boundary or vocal-comfort zone. Never shown any dynamic or progress. Never has dared to be half the vocal acrobat Rihanna is. Just listen to their discographies.

Rihanna has proven she is able to take on a myriad of genres & pull it off quite effortlessly. She has successfully expressed anger, pain, wrath, vulnerability, power, success, defiance, sensuality and even apathy through her vocals.

Gaga has the same tone & vocal techniques throughout all her music, there is little vocal-variation. She could not, for example, ever pull the emotional-vulnerability of something like "Stay" Or "Love The Way You Lie". The attitude of "Hard" or the seduction of "Skin". She's too... Broadway.

Originally posted by FOCK

Gaga may be a great vocalist, but she has never stepped out of any boundary or vocal-comfort zone. Never shown any dynamic or progress. Never has dared to be half the vocal acrobat Rihanna is. Just listen to their discographies.

Rihanna has proven she is able to take on a myriad of genres & pull it off quite effortlessly. She has successfully expressed anger, pain, wrath, vulnerability, power, success, defiance, sensuality and even apathy through her vocals.

Gaga has the same tone & vocal techniques throughout all her music, there is little vocal-variation. She could not, for example, ever pull the emotional-vulnerability of something like "Stay" Or "Love The Way You Lie". The attitude of "Hard" or the seduction of "Skin". She's too... Broadway.

Originally posted by Dark Miracles

You don't believe that. Lady Gaga would pull off those songs way better than Rihanna does.