Gaga >>>>>. Truly workin it and moving that bitch crazy. I remember this so well, everyone made gifs of Government Hooker then and of the models who stumbled wearing the same platform heels that Gaga wore. But Gaga, like a pro, worked them 12 inch heels like the bitch has been in the modelling business for 10 years. I can't believe it has been two years since.
This may come off like a shade towards my fave but the GP (aka normal people) actually knew about Rihanna's catwalk and of course they'd prefer it.
The Gaga's performance was praised by high fashion critics but sadly (for you) 99% of GP doesn't understand high fashion and even find it weird (like I do).
So my answer is: It depends on whom you ask (99% it would be Rihanna because people at least know about it).