TV Show: American Idol: Season 12 Finale - Page 90

Elusive Chanteuse

There is nothing soulful about this girls voice. She is a country singer.

yogosans14

You could tell she was agrrivated this episode, espically that comment when Nicki asked that one girl if she could borrow her bra or something and Mariah was like "No Nicki that bra wouldn't fit you" I could tell it really ticked Nicki off.

Gossip_Boy

I agree with Nicki. Why do they always have to put people in a box? Why can't the girl just sing what she wants to sing? That's exactly what's wrong with the music industry today. Everybody is trying to do what they think everyone wants them to do.

Them fighting like that in front of everybody was unprofessional, though.

TheAqua

Quote:

Originally posted by fortheloveofmusic

They were both "right" but also both wrong.

Nicki obviously hates when someone is pressured into talking about what genre they want to be in since she was bashed for "going pop." You can tell that it still bothers her, and is an insecurity.

Randy and Mariah weren't pressuring her into being a country star. They were just trying to get a feel for what she wanted to be. Yes, Nicki was right that it was too early for her to choose, but if this was a record label they would ask the SAME EXACT QUESTION. If she wants to do her own thing she can just be indie, but those questions would come up sooner or later.

Randy's "30 year comment" was a cut to Nicki's pride and was uncalled for, but she didn't have to walk off the panel like a 5 year old. She could have said "Can I have one minute" and walked away then came back. All of the yelling was stupid and made her look like bad guy even though Randy was instigating the fight just as much.

Nicki needs to stop taking the "artist questions" so personal Mariah and Randy shouldn't have ganged up on her, but they weren't wrong at all for asking the girl those questions. Did it feel like an interrogation at points? Yes

@ this long ass post

inagalaxyfar

i LOOOVE her

TheAqua

Quote:

Originally posted by yogosans14

You could tell she was agrrivated this episode, espically that comment when Nicki asked that one girl if she could borrow her bra or something and Mariah was like "No Nicki that bra wouldn't fit you" I could tell it really ticked Nicki off.

Which is sad, because Mariah was just playing with Nicki...

"Gurl bye"

Nicki had been In a stank ass mood the whole damn show,she'd been rolling her eyes, moving uncomfortably in her chair since the show came on. It just built up in that moment with the Country girl auditioning.

I think Onika was just having a bad day.She even said she had an attitude last year.

Ivan_brit

OMG!!!!! so there were actually more figths between Nicki & The Panel

I think it was a stupid fight tbh, Idol should stop doing this!! this is only hurting the show!!

Willy.

Quote:

Originally posted by brandnewdrew

I get where Nicki came from and I can actually understand her getting defensive over the other judges immediately trying to "pigeonhole" this girl in some ways. Nicki has had equal hands in rap and pop and as someone who gets criticized by the hip-hop community for stepping so heavily into pop sometimes, it's understandable for her to be annoyed by them basically trying to make this girl say "Ok, I'm a country singer". Granted, people don't fare well in this competition without a decided upon "sound" and image, but I do get her being irritated. Also, Mariah kind of came across like a bitch with the way she seemed to be condescending Nicki in the discussion. Randy as well, particularly by implying that because of his experience, he was properly trying to help this girl, which in turn did kind of insinuate that someone with just a few years in the game like Nicki could not do the same. She did kind of overreact a bit while walking off, but I can't say she was totally wrong here.

Of course.

Willy.

Quote:

Originally posted by TheAqua

Which is sad, because Mariah was just playing with Nicki...

"Gurl bye"

Nicki had been In a stank ass mood the whole damn show,she'd been rolling her eyes, moving uncomfortably in her chair since the show came on. It just built up in that moment with the Country girl auditioning.

I think Onika was just having a bad day.She even said she had an attitude last year.

Oh please, Mariah's been salty the moment they told her another female would be on the show.

I'd imagine she's still salty considering every critic sides with Nicki.

Willy.

Less than 25 minutes.

Rigalo

Quote:

Originally posted by Willy.

The Black rocker girl also reminded me of Azealia

First thing I thought of. Lmao

Willy.

It's on.

Taste of Honey

Yes. Sounding like Legend X.

Doc

That girl is great!

Willy.

AMAZING voice!

yogosans14

Perfect voice and attitude!

and @Aqua...please, like I care for your biased opinion.

I ithink Mariah is a good judge, I just didn't like that comment. BYE

KevinKDC

Mariah is very boring tbh. Nicki and Keith are deff the judges on the panel.

Doc

Oh, and by the way, I'm definitely on Team Nicki. I can understand both sides, but Nicki's side felt more right A), and B) Mariah and Randy were just plain rude.

Maybe I'll go into more detail later.

slw84

YASS Nicki what's the second thing that matured...hmmm

yogosans14

That thing Nicki just did to Mariah was kind unnecessary...