But, is that helping her career though? At the end of the day you can get talked about in the media all you want,but, if that's not helping your career it really means nothing. Plus, being known as "[Insert name here]'s girlfriend" should be pretty annoying to the Selena stans because even though I don't like the girl, she works hard and is a good role model.

Wait ! WHAT?

I'm not sure if it helped her sales but now everyone knows who she is. Demi Lovato dated Joe Jonas when the Jonas Brothers were huge and it didn't generate the same media attention. Something Selena and Justin must have that it attracts so many headlines..

I'm not even a Selena stan I'm just saying she is relevant..

Hilary

I thought this thread was about impact.

There's two questions to answer. I think...

nah he deleted the question about impact. now it's just who is more relevant

I'm sorry about that. I erased the word impact from the OP cause there would be a clear winner. I mostly meant relevancy.

when Demi dated Joe Jonas the Jonas brothers were already fading and being overshadowed by Bieber, he's obviously a way bigger name so they attracted more headlines

And has Hilary ever had such memorable and iconic singles?

Why Not, So Yesterday, Come Clean >>>>>

Hilary was only close to the Top 20 twice:
Wake Up: 29
With Love: 24

Selena has been closer to breaking the Top 20 more times..
Naturally: 29
Round & Round: 24
Love You Like a Love Song: 22
Who Says: 21

So Yesterday and Come Clean both peaked at #15 & #9 on top 40 radio. So Yesterday was Hilary's only single to get a physical release in the US. That release in early August helped it peak early long before it peaked on radio. Come Clean didn't get a physical release and digital sales were not only nearly non-existent, they weren't accounted for on the Hot 100.

Wake Up was released when digital sales began actually making an impact and were included on the Hot 100, but didn't sell well enough as a single download because the album experienced such great sales.

With Love was released when R&B & Hip Hop absolutely dominated radio. There was barely any room for pop music on those formats that didn't come from saps like the guy who sang Beautiful & few others.

Give it a rest. You are obviously a Hilary hater.

the op says nothing about selena
RN Selena and hasnt peaked yet

Come Clean is more memorable than Selena's whole career.

You just went up a little in my book for that hot tea.

but if see WW Selena is way more famous i mean love song is still charting inside top 100 in itunes of so many countries
but no doubt that hilary had a great impact in us

Girl, you know I stan for Lindsay. What are you saying?

Obviously the Queen of Disney, Hilary Duff. If it wasn't for her, we wouldn't have people like Selena, Demi, etc. Selena Gomez is only relevant as of now because she's dating Justin Bieber, and that's a fact.