Quote:
Originally posted by dinorel
Yes basically you are ...
and who says she is supposed to give constructive critisism during a performance?.
Every judge has a style , she gives her constructive critisism when she is mentoring , otherwise her job as a judge is just saying if she aproves or not the performance, thats it, if other judges want to speak more thats their problem.
|
Umm, maybe because that's what a judge is SUPPOSED to do.
What do you think their job is then? Just to say useless comments like Britney about how "they just don't get it" without explaining what is they don't or how some one's performance was "right on" and nothing else?
No, that's not how it works. And no that's not just what I think, that's how it IS and has ALWAYS been.
It's funny how Nicole was so hated last year when she puts Britney to shame judging wise on th UK version.
Quote:
Originally posted by Anthony K.
|
