More Impressive: Madonna or Mariah? (Read before voting)
Quote:
Simple question, simple answer. Below, you will find all the Top 10s on Billboard Hot 100 chart by Madonna and Mariah. Which one do you find more impressive? Mariah having eighteen #1 but barely any other top 10 let alone top 3 or Madonna having twelve #1s, ten top 3 songs and tens of top 10 hits more?
Artist
#1s
#2s
#3s
Top 10s
Years making the Top 10
Madonna
12
6
4
38
28 years (30 years - 2 missing)
Mariah
18
3
1
27
19 years (22 years - 3 missing)
Madonna
Twelve #1s:
Like A Virgin (1984)
Crazy For You (1985)
Live To Tell (1986)
Papa Don't Preach (1986)
Open Your Heart (1987)
Who's That Girl (1987)
Like A Prayer (1989)
Vogue (1990)
Justify My Love (1991)
This Used To Be My Playground (1992)
Take A Bow (1995)
Music (2000)
Six #2s:
Material Girl (1985)
Causing a Commotion (1987)
Cherish (1989)
Express Yourself (1989)
I'll Remember (1994)
Frozen (1998)
Four #3s:
True Blue (1986)
Erotica (1992)
Secret (1994)
4 Minutes (2008)
Mariah
Eighteen #1s:
Vision of Love (1990)
Love Takes Time (1990)
Someday (1991)
I Don't Wanna Cry (1991)
Emotions (1991)
I'll Be There (1992)
Hero (1993)
Dreamlover (1993)
One Sweet Day (1995)
Fantasy (1995)
Always Be My Baby (1996)
Honey (1997)
My All (1998)
Heartbreaker (1999)
Thank God I Found You (2000)
We Belong Together (2005)
Don't Forget About Us (2005)
Touch My Body (2008)
Three #2s:
Can't Let Go (1992)
Loverboy (2001)
Shake It Off (2005)
I think Madonna's longevity is a little more impressive. But I hate these things because both have done things their contemporaries wish they could achieve.
Madonna
