I'm here for a Cheryl & Mel B panel. As long as they kick Louis to the curb. He's tired.

If Simon cannot return, I'd be here for:

Nicole Scherzy
Robbie Williams
Cheryl Cole
Louis Walsh

Now THAT would be an amazing panel - I mean, Robbie would stand for Cheryl and Louis would go for Nicole. Or maybe it could happen the unexpected

I'd be here for Cheryl, Nicole, Tulisa and Louis.

3 women on the panel. Why not?

Gary would also stand for Cheryl.

I love Cheryl

No matter who Simon gets on the show, it won't save the ratings. The show is past its sell-by date. It peaked in 2010, and now people are simply losing interest. The format has become stale, and everything has become predictable.

No Cheryl NOOOOOOOOOO!

This is a sinking ship, don't go back even if he pays you 3 times more of what you got before, no!

Simon & Cheryl need to bring this show back.

This but X Factor US won't do it.

About the U 2010 was flawless and nothing will top it. I don't think she should go back. It is only downhill.

It's hilarious how far Simon has fallen in just a few short years.

Two years ago XF had massive ratings in the UK and he was returning to America with the OMG BIGGEST SHOW IN THE WORLD EVARRRR. Now, he doesn't have the same pull in either country as he used to and XF is flopping in both.

This is what happens when you get greedy, Simon.

THIS

Its not Cheryl missing that killed the show it was the very much obvious fixing of the results and the gimmick acts added for no reason other then to make headlines nothing can save it now

yes
Simon knows the true tea, cheryl is a true entertainmenttttttt

I'd be here for this. Not only is Nicole great, but the dynamic between Cheryl and Nicole would be really interesting.

And lets not forget Louis, he and Cheryl seem to have fallen out since she left and he has been slagging her off quite a bit, so I could see them constantly sparring.

If Gary stays it would be good too as he and Cheryl are good friends.