Poll: Bigger Impact: Ke$ha or Christina Aguilera? - Page 6

Giselle

Quote:

Originally posted by Xenomania

Ke$ha, obviously.

Christina is already done, really... I thought nothing could be commercially worse than Bionic, but Lotus made me change my mind.

Ke$ha has yet to dominate the world, as she's already done with TiK ToK. A lot of albums will eventually be released, depicting her experimental and vulnerable side and, gradually, people will take her more seriously and she'll become a legend.

None of that has to do with impact though.

ks_dollar

Quote:

Originally posted by FelixMonster

that's really sad.

where did you grow up?

I grew up in the city of Brisbane in Australia, the third most popular city here. Maybe I have heard those songs before, it might just be they're extremely forgettable.

Rolland

Quote:

Originally posted by Xenomania

Are you stupid or something?

You're now making a comparison between totally different periods of time. Back then, it was very common to sell like 800,000+ in a week and reaching 20M+ sales worldwide, since the piracy levels were much lower and the Internet wasn't as huge as it is nowadays.

NEVERTHELESS, Ke$ha adapted herself to this virtual and digital current world and is getting bigger and bigger, whereas Xtina keeps flopping harder and harder.

Oh, looks like someone's mad.

Anyway, seems like I am not the stupid one in here. Since I never mentioned any numbers at all.

I just said Xtina had it all with her debut, while Kesha only got a successful debut single. Is that really hard to understand?

At you resuming Xtina's career in two albums. The desperation.

Quote:

Originally posted by ks_dollar

Ke$ha under-performed with her debut album? :sis: For a debut album that's sold well more over 3 million it did good. Besides you can't even tell if she 'under-performed' with that album if you have no other album to compare it to (yet)

I compared it to the newbies releasing at the same time. And especially with Gaga and Perry. She had to make a rerelease and even with that she failed to have success with her album. Oh, and 3 million my ass.

ks_dollar

Quote:

Originally posted by Lord_Byron28

So you think the millions tuning in to watch the voice every week don't know who Christina is? Gurl bye.

They all know the the artist who currently has a #3 song, than the artist who's latest single peaked at #34.

BKzREVENGE

Kesha is coooooooooool !

but

Luigi

Quote:

Originally posted by Xenomania

I don't even remember Dirrty's or Hurt's lyrics.

Well good for you, but you don't equate to the general public.
And please, Dirrty is well remembered.

The music video and the song both had huge controversies surrounding each other and they're still talked about today.

Quote:

Originally posted by ks_dollar

:I've never even heard those songs before. All of Ke$ha's singles are clearly more memorable than Xtine's sorry. The only song the GP can slightly remember is Beautiful.

I can't.

Giselle

Quote:

Originally posted by iHypeMusic

Let's not get ahead of ourselves now. Especially with Not Myself Tonight or Your Body both peaked higher and had no impact whatsoever.

Chart Positions =/= Impact though.

ks_dollar

Quote:

Originally posted by Rolland

Oh, looks like someone's mad.

Anyway, seems like I am not the stupid one in here. Since I never mentioned any numbers at all.

I just said Xtina had it all with her debut, while Kesha only got a successful debut single. Is that really hard to understand?

At you resuming Xtina's career in two albums. The desperation.

I compared it to the newbies releasing at the same time. And especially with Gaga and Perry. She had to make a rerelease and even with that she failed to have success with her album. Oh, and 3 million my ass.

The other artists that released around the same time as her doesn't influence the success of her album

It has sold a fine amount and obviously didn't under perform. Anyways, last time I checked the thread was about something else

gotintoririfever1

Quote:

Originally posted by iHypeMusic

Yes, because when is the last time they were brought up majorly?

2006?

Girl bye.

i cant

girl when r u born seriously?

dirrty is the epitome of dirrty sexual songs and artists

everything about xtina is iconic

Giselle

Quote:

Originally posted by Rolland

Xtina got a massive debut single, so did Kesha. Xtina got massive success with her debut album, Kesha she underperformed. Xtina got a BNA Grammy award, was Kesha even nominated? So, if we are going to make a "fair" comparison then there you go.

Clocked.

Giselle

Quote:

Originally posted by ks_dollar

I've never even heard those songs before. All of Ke$ha's singles are clearly more memorable than Xtine's sorry. The only song the GP can slightly remember is Beautiful. I can't even remember the name of the last solo Xtina single apart from YB and the one about not being herself or something?

Sis, are you like 12?

K@rm@

Like how old are these Kesha stans?

They haven't heard of Dirrty(her most memorable video)or Hurt(her biggest European hit). and Think just because kesha has been more successful the last 3 years than Christina she has had a bigger impact? a ****ing mess.

ks_dollar

Quote:

Originally posted by Rolland

Xtina got a massive debut single, so did Kesha. Xtina got massive success with her debut album, Kesha she underperformed. Xtina got a BNA Grammy award, was Kesha even nominated? So, if we are going to make a "fair" comparison then there you go.

Well thing is mate you've only compared one sector of both's career, and that can't determine who's entire impact will be bigger. Ke$ha hasn't had 7 albums so to compare the rest you're going to need a crystal ball or wait until these 5 albums arrive. Why doesn't the OP compare Xtina to someone with or around 7 albums

Rolland

Going by Kesha stans' logic, Los del Rio had/made more impact than Madonna or Michael Jackson. Good to know, it seems clever. RIGHT?

ks_dollar

Quote:

Originally posted by RaeseanLohan

Sis, are you like 12?

No. I'm 17. + Like I said before it's not a matter of me not hearing these songs, it's a matter of how forgettable they are.

gotintoririfever1

it doesn't mean that u all didn't saw/feel the success of xtina since almost of Rafle$ha's here are only 6-12 year olds, it doesn't mean that it didn't happened

just like mj's success, almost of us weren't there when mj was slaying and yet still we acknowledge his success :micheal:

Early_Mornin

Xtina.
The little girl with the big voice.

Concept & Theory

Quote:

Originally posted by K@rm@

Like how old are these Kesha stans?

They haven't heard of Dirrty(her most memorable video)or Hurt(her biggest European hit). and Think just because kesha has been more successful the last 3 years than Christina she has had a bigger impact? a ****ing mess.

I know Dirrty's video but I don't think it was iconic at all.

Sorry, but I don't even know Hurt (maybe I do as soon as I listen to it, but not by its name).

I'm 18, btw.