Well, she could pull a Katy Perry and release a blockbuster second album...

I won't count her out but I won't be checking for her

Although Katy's second single was a smash hit WW while This Kiss...

Maybe we could look at it like this

Call me maybe=I kissed a girl (big #1 hit)
Good time=hot n cold (somewhat big top ten hit)
This kiss=thinking of you (flop)
????=waking up in Vegas (modest top ten hit)
???=California girls (huge hit that established Katy for good and mags Carly?)

Carly's second single was Good Time and was a smash hit. You can sit.

Yep. Her album sales underwhelmed and This Kiss flopped. Good Time only smashed because of the momentum from Call Me Maybe. She's over.

No, but she picked an awful single.
She needs Turn me Up or Hurts So Good!

Sis, Hot N Cold was much bigger than Good Time and it smashed after IKAG had already peaked, which proved that she wouldn't be a one hit wonder. Good Time and CMM smashed almost simultaneously, and after they peaked, all of her hype died. Carly is over.

I love This Kiss, perfect follow up imo., weird how people loved Call me Maybe over this.
But maybe she should just work on her image a bit?
I have a feeling that people know her name just because of CMM and not because she's an interesting person.
Not saying, she should dress extravagant or anything but you know, I think that she's too boring for people to really remember her name without hearing CMM.

Her album is great though !

Yes. Nobody cared about her before CMM and nobody will care about her after it. Being a one-hit wonder isn't too bad, though - you can get pretty rich off of one hit song.

Probably, but I voted for it's too soon.

I feel like she should release a new album or have a rerelease single. To recover from a flop she needs another song that grabs your attention right away. Another call me
Maybe might be unrealistic but the rest of this album doesn't have anything like that. Very decent songs yes, but not immediate singles. And with everyone having such different opinions on what should be next, I think that shows how shaky this is. She needs to have a song where everyone hears it and whether they like the song or not know that that song has that x factor that would make it be the perfect single

Hopefully. I couldn't take another year of this.

Yes Her album sales underwhelmed and This Kiss flopped.

yes. she is boring and CMM is awful.

She'll release two more albums and disappear from the face of the universe.
Girl bye.

You can't be a one hit wonder if you have two hits.

I promise Onkia will be there too.

I never saw her having a career/longevity after CMM in the first place