what makes you think she thinks that she knows as much as Simon?

I'm sure she knows that Simon knows more. She just probably felt attacked because he kept acting extremely rude and attacking not just her contestants but everything she said. She already said she's going to change things next week.

No way she's amazing

Yes. She's a fantastic judge though

Yes she's terrible

Bad judge, bad mentor.

Vacuous comments when judging, and she's got the best age category- she should be slaying it with the quality of acts she has, not lagging along.

No lol, just because you don't like how her contestants look makes her a bad mentor?
bye.

All of her contestants are actually really happy with the choices Demi has made.

because she disagrees with him probably

the logic of some atrl members just wants to make me cry.

You guys can say whatever you want about her. But it's just first two weeks. She has the riskiest contestant who you know it's Cece. Okay she has the packages, but she's already got so much hates since the first audition. Demi just wants to help her with this problem and we know it's not that easy to change ppl's mind if a lot of ppl already hated her first and don't give her the chances. And probably because of that case a lot of ppl who dislike her just want her to fail in the show and reliazed her mistake (like something karma) with not vote for her. And if this the main factor, you can't blame everything to Demi. I still love Cece though because I don't believe everything that made from tv show because they can script everything for get ppl attentions.
And who knows what happens in the next week, just wait and see.

No. She's just new to this, she'll improve in due time.

Yes, she's horrible. At least she's a decent judge.

Terrible mentor, alright judge. I don't know why Simon hired her. She hasn't experienced that many things and it shows.

What? CiCi was ALWAYS hated. And her giving terrible vocal performances on the live shows sure as hell isn't Demi's fault.

Jennel loves and feels comfortable with her new look and she's still being praised for her performances. Paige is doing her thing and the judges like her even after Demi put her hands on her. Ya'll do too much.

The only wrong Demi has done, was sending Jillian Jensen home. That girl was likeable, just look at her audition views/comments/likes.

When it comes to other acts, Demi is a great judge. But when it comes to her contestants, she fails to take any other judge's CONSTRUCTIVE criticism and instead cuts them off immaturely like she did with Simon several times this week. She fails to see the flaws or mistakes her contestants are making, and that will be their biggest downfall.

The style of her contestants were changed to something theyre not, but that can always be changed even after the show.She needs to stop with the over-productions of her contestants and focus more on their vocal talents to get them thru the competition.

Overall, she should be doing better and everybody expected her to be a lot better, esp better than Britney who is doing a fabulous job as a mentor. She's a great girl and singer, but she is too inexperienced as an artist and as a person in the music industry.

U only come to the Demi threads to HATE on Her! It's obvious that you don't like her! and it's not her fault!! She's trying her best to be a Good Mentor! She's been doing a GREAT JOB with Paige and Jennel!! and Cece well not that much but she is also showing lack of vocal technique (sometimes she goes out of pitch) so don't blame it all on her!!

YES she is
the way she's ruining Cece is not mainly because of the song choice or the makeover

the reason why Cece slaying Ain't No OTher Man is she sang it with confidence and an attitude
now when Demi told her to be "likeable" and take those leopard dots off, she became a shy and scared girl. She's always shaky on stage

for Jennel, the new look just makes her look bland and unoriginal
i don't like Paige for the very start so .....

What kinda flop logic? so basically according to you, everyone can sing, act etc right?

if that was the case then talent shows would've never existed and Britney is a horrible judge and I'm not saying this just to back up my fave like you do.

she NEVER criticizes the contestants, EVER. I suggest you to grow up and stop going to every Demi thread and try to put her down, I mean at least try to make sense instead of being a bad troll.

and she's already a superstar, she might not be as successful as Britney or anyone else but Simon hired her ass for a reason and she's the ONLY one who's getting positive reviews and benefiting the most from the show.

Demi is not a terrible mentor, y'all are saying this because you want to find at least one problem in her imo, I mean yeah she's not GREAT either but she's NOT terrible.