I don't see what this has to do with Beyoncé, but it doesn't prove she didn't lose fans after Birthday Cake (Remix).

IF it were released. That's the key word, because it never happened. (Personally, I feel like it would've gone top 20, nothing more. It's way too Urban to be a big hit on Pop)

Where the f**k is Ke$ha?

Luv, you need to understand what makes up a fanbase.

Fanbase is the core fans that stand strong throughout the good (success), the bad (downfall/missteps) and ugly (the aged pop star, new it girl and fickle public).
Fair weathers are the ones that are here when it is cool.

to answer the question, it is obviously Britney.
Many of these girls still have not been tested for longevity and resiliency once the tide turns against them and for other it girls.

Britney has gone through the good, bad and ugly and has consistently shifted and evolved to remain relevant (whether personally or professionally). She has done so being the aspiration of what goods wanted to be and guys wanted to be with at the onset of her career, transition to someone that seemed more approachable and relatable (making poor decision and rebelling) to the public transitioned to a trainwreck (self-destructing, party girl) that could not own her mistakes and completely became broken then transition to a comeback kid inspiring others that have fallen to not play a victim and pick themselves up and now an older wiser experienced iconic legend that is respected for her contributions to pop culture. Throughout that she has maintained the charm, charisma, one of a kind, incomparable persona and keen instinct to maintain her position ensuring she made great videos, music, innovative and trend setting career choices, stage shows etc. As a result, she has maintained a loyal fanbase that has garnered 7 consecutive platinum albums and scored her many accolades (best selling female artist of the 21st century, best selling teenage artist, first female to...youngest female artist to...). That could only done with the help of a loyal fanbase.


Like, seriously how could you even compare with the list you have. No one else on the list has been tested and gone through the shifts and able to maintain as consistent as Britney Spears

You're welcome.

BEYHIVE & The Army.

That's not entirely true. Many Britney fans have had a point where they decided to let go for a minute but came back during album release.
She still goes platinum because she still produces hits. She still sells out concerts because she (i won't talk about the dancing) is an entertainer that puts on a good show.

If she produced flops and just stood in front of a green screen sitting down the whole time while in concert and her fans still supported then yes it would be too much. But that is not the case.

It's mainly the Army, we've stuck with her no matter what. Also the Beyhive is loyal.

Britney's because they stuck by her through that troubled time in her life.

And it's also amazing how some new fans came during/after the breakdown, fully aware of what happened and they still stan for her.

Also, the Christina stans take A LOT of **** here and on twitter to support their fave.

And we all know the BeyHive goes hard.

Those three in that order.

I would agree that Britney stans are too loyal. That, IMO, is because she represents their childhood. Like an old teddy bear that has been beaten, chewed up, and torn...they still adore it. For that, Britney has the most loyal.

Beyonce and Gaga fall right behind her. The monsters have such an Internet presence that they make headlines for actually buying Gaga's music + tickets, as well as "defending" her.

The others fan bases need to start saving up their coins and show a little support!!

Britney Spears

And even if the girls did lose all these fans, doesn't that make the fans they still have even more loyal for staying by their fave when the others left?

Probably little monsters I think

The people is really saying Rihanna, really?
i mean how many copies sold diamonds on its first week?
If she has so many devoted fans why they don't buy her music? ;rolleyes:

Britney comes next

Gaga and Bey

Britney, Gaga, and Beyonce.

Gaga, but that doesn't mean it's a good thing.

They viciously attack anyone opposed to Gaga and are big enough to push an entire celebrity into media hell (Kelly Osbourne). Even the media has reported their bullying notoriety.

But hey, they're loyal.

.

Lady Gaga and Britney

Kelly. Her fans basically grew up with her and have been with her even through her My December era and other rough times. I think it needs tough times to prove true fans.