Celeb News: Xtina slams X Factor - Page 3

Toxicity.

Quote:

Originally posted by Mhs90

I actually REALLY liked the idea of The Voice, but that show probably has the worst contestants out of any singing talent show which is why I can't follow it. And the format is really awkward

X factor may ride the stereotype train a lot but at least they have extremely talented contestants IMO. And, since when do we not stereotype artists into genres?

Drag ha sis

thegmangrant

She obviously doesn't understand the X Factor. That's what the show is about - I mean Christina can't act like her voice (despite it being a very powerful voice) has been the only thing to her through her career.

That is what being a star is about.

Hence why The Voice can't produce a star.

Beautiful Sinner

Quote:

Originally posted by WarriorQueen

But that's what the "X Factor" is

It's about finding a true star who can have a real career afterwards, you can have an amazing voice but if you're not marketable you won't make it in the music industry.

Right.

WarriorQueen

Quote:

Originally posted by Rolland

Did she lie?

Oh, and before talking about X Factor making stars, look at her winner...

The X Factor series has produced many stars. Stop.

skyler

Quote:

Originally posted by GreasyBruce

I hope no one was injured.

Rolland

Quote:

Originally posted by WarriorQueen

The X Factor series has produced many stars. Stop.

Not in the US edition.

AlexandriaANTM

X factor is finding a star while the Voice is finding the Voice??

From this season of XF, I can see that Beatrice, Carly and Diamond will be a success because either Disney or Nickelodeon will call her.
Janell Garcia, Paige Thomas and Cece Frey has a bright future them.
All the groups has a big career in front of them like LYLAS, Playback, Lyric 145 and Sister C (country love them)
And I can even see Jason Brock performing on a big stage for a spectacular live show at Las Vegas

Rated R

Quote:

Originally posted by Mhs90

So true!

The mentors on X factor also get competitive but they don't go to such limits as the Voice judges do. IF they had cared about the contestants, we would have had at LEAST ONE successful artists from the past 3 seasons of the Voice....

Exactly. Nobody has even checked on the winners.
All the judges and Carson talk about is which of the judges have won the past seasons. That competition is a ploy to get them more exposure so Christina can sit

MusicTalker

She's right, but The Voice is hardly different from the shows she dissed after the show's lifeline blind audition rounds.

Singing competitions are awful now.

AlexandriaANTM

Quote:

Originally posted by Rolland

Not in the US edition.

At least they have a moderate success, not like The Voice, where the winner is crowned and you never heard them again

KevinKDC

Quote:

Originally posted by GreasyBruce

I hope no one was injured.

kdadlksadlk

Sinningfighter

She's been saying this since last year so I don't get why it's only being brought up now as if it's some shocking revelation.

thegmangrant

Quote:

Originally posted by Rolland

Not in the US edition.

Even the 3rd place Winner of X Factor US Chris Rene had a song that charted in the Top 40 Radio at #26.

Toxicity.

Quote:

Originally posted by Rolland

Not in the US edition.

There's only been 1 prior season.

FameFatale

She could be talkin about Idol too.

Fireman25

I get what she is saying, but she doesn't realize that X Factor is more about the 'whole package' that's why they say stuff like that. Why do you think they got rid of that guy in the wheelchair or Panda? They can sing, but they don't have that typical 'superstar look'. The Voice is more about the talent.

Gabriel_Spears

She better stop doing this kind of interviews and start promoting her single.

Run The World

i see no lies

AlexandriaANTM

The coaches on The Voice didn't care about their contestant except themselves. They just used the show to promote themselves.

rihannabiggestfan

Quote:

Originally posted by AlexandriaANTM

Let's be honest, 75% of X Factor contestant gonna have an amazing career while only one of The Voice contestant will have a success and that is Casadee Hope

Cassadee Pope is already somewhat successful though ... Glee covered one of her songs