I've been to a PCD concerts and like 95 % off people there we're cheering for Melody and ashley.



Good days.

Yes seriously. Mel was the true HBIC of the PCD and that's why Nicole didn't want ha to be in the spotlight most of the time. Unlike the the other girls , Mel had the voice and the moves , She was a danger to Nicole and Nicole knew that very well.

You obviously did not watch that video. Melody clearly did not have the voice nor was she a threat to Nicole. There's a reason why Robin Antin hired Nicole to be front and center (it wasn't Nicole own doing) and Melody wasn't even on stage for most of that performance.

I wonder why ?...LOL

Everything in this video TBQH <3.

This isn't new information.

On their second album, several of the songs were just placed on it from Her Name is Nicole sessions how they were before.

All the other girls did on Jai Ho was dance in the video. I found it very unfair they were credited, when Nicole did all the work for it by herself.

Mess

But I thought the girls had lines and background vocals

They tried to credit Hush Hush; Hush Hush as PCD feat Nicole too, but the girls bitched and it was changed.

Because she was told not to be? I mean, it's difficult to figure out why. Again, did you watch the AMAs video?

That was good, but unfortunately Melody isn't very versatile as evidenced by every Buttons performance. Nicole is:



It was supposed to be Nicole's single with AR Rahman, but PCD's name was added to it at the last minute by the label.

Um no, I've been to PCD concerts myself and even during the intro vids people cheer the loudest for Nicole, she has the biggest fanbase. During their solo songs people only really cheered when they had dance breaks, which is what Kimberley and Ashley had.

Just because you don't like Nicole doesn't mean that Melody is so much better than her. Nicole was rightfully their lead singer. Melody joined the PCD at 19 without having any prior training in singing or dancing, which lead to her not having enough vocal control and being the weakest dancer in the group. Nicole is a trained singer who had plenty of recording experience and while not being a trained dancer still was the third best dancer in the group. Plus, Melody has an urban voice with a rasp to it, you can't sing pop music with that.

Besides, you can't tell me you went to a PCD concert and was left unimpressed with Nicole when she sings everything live from the first till the last second while still dancing as hard as the other girls. I don't care how much you hate her, you can't deny her talent.

jessica forgot her top and she was obv eating all the cakes backstage.

Good points! I love it!

Thank you.

For the record, Nicole isn't even on Santa Baby

^ That song is from 2003, long before Robin wanted to turn PCD into a music group and hired Nicole.

tbh that song is DAMN old like Inverted said and beside that it was a B-side

What the hell was she on?