Poll: Talent: Xtina or P!nk? - Page 6

jomarr

X>

Pink is great tho.

dperkins

Quote:

Originally posted by SwagLikeALegend

While TTAL is more tame and commercial than Try This, the songs have the same purpose and sound obviously. The ballads and the feisty songs. I mean there's not even a clear distinction in the image. I found her Greatest Hits photoshoots heavily mirrored Try This.

Christina's "Fighter" is her key empowerment song and no other songs in her collection can parallel it. P!nk's "Blow Me" is basically another "So What."

So we're slamming Pink for having an identity?

Also I don't think her songs sound all the same. Yes she has a similar layout for albums, but each album is different in where her life is.

She's still got more talent in her pinky than Christina does in her whole body. Christina can sing, and that's about it. She writes occasionally, but not that much anymore, I haven't really seen her dance in lord knows how long, and she has yet to master singing live while in the air.

dperkins

Quote:

Originally posted by fanoftalent

I think you're judging Pink based on first singles only. TTAL is very diverse. It has a rock tune, a pop rock tune, a pop tune, a country folk ballad, an R'n'B song, a throwback 60s jam, an urban song.

Critics also agree that Pink's albums are better. TTAL got a very high score for a pop album standards.

While I think Xtina's first singles are all a mess, I don't deny that she's capable of coming up with better things and You Lost Me remains one of my all time favorite songs. But she's definitely not ahead of Pink when it comes to reinventions. Image - maybe. But musically, which is more important, Pink stays more creative.

These girls are probably just listening to her singles. I don't think ANY song on TTAL sounds like another song on that album. Each song sounds different.

Chileno

P!nk as a whole.

P!nkInside

P!nk doesn't reinvent her sound? What is that person smoking?!?!

No other pop has attempted more genres than P!nk has.

CTMH - R&B with flavors of hip-hop.
M!ss - Reinvention of pop-rock with some dance influences.
Try This - 'Garage' rock and punk (totally old school, it was even recorded in 2 weeks)
IND - Commercial Pop/rock
FH - Commercial Pop/rock
TTAL - (except Blow Me) A Vintage sound. Basically pop/rock but with influences of ska, new wave. A few critics descriptions for example: Try - an ’80s-influenced soft rock number; How Come You're Not Here - Pink channels Joan Jett, Janis Joplin, and Melissa Etheridge on speed; **** Like You - punk–country-western hybrid; Just Give Me A Reason - ’70s-feeling ballad; Title Track - 60s vibe something like Nancy Sinatra.

So ya'll can take several seats. And P!nk and her lyrical masterpieces due to which she has been dubbed as the best songwriter in pop music are cackling at the ignorant 'not a good song-writer' comments

DejaVu

Pink is the better writer & the better singer by miles.

They're about tied when it comes to dancing.

Writing - Pink by a large amount
Singing - Pink by a large amount
Instruments - Pink by a large amount
Dancing - tied
Overall creativity with their shows - Christina by a large amount

P!nk wins.

N@te

P!nk and it's not even questionable.