Poll: Should Nicki Minaj be fired? - Page 4

Mr Telephone Man

No, she didn't act up for no reason. If Mariah was constantly patronizing her and picking on her, doesn't that amount to "bullying". Both that and fighting aren't good for the workplace.

So she should get fired for standing up for herself? But Mariah should get off for verbally assaulting her first? Whatever you may think of Nicki the artist, the video MORE than supports that this is an ongoing problem she has had to deal with against Mariah

So no, if Mariah gets off. So should she.

bey0nce

Yes, it's a family show, she might scare the little children watching and nobody wants that

Vin

Quote:

Originally posted by jayyyxtee

Ahhh very good point A LOT of kids watch this show and believe no parent is going to want their children watching Nicki go off like that.

One could even argue that Nicki Minaj and this drama is actually tarnishing American Idol's
brand. It's interesting that people feel they will promote this feud, but that probably will
not be the case, because "drama" isn't American Idol's claim to fame. American
Idol caters to the middle-America conservatives demographic. These are
not the same people who watch Kardashians and "Real Housewives."

...Vin

Devon

Quote:

Originally posted by Vin

One could even argue that Nicki Minaj and this drama is actually tarnishing American Idol's
brand. It's interesting that people feel they will promote this feud, but that probably will
not be the case, because "drama" isn't American Idol's claim to fame. American
Idol caters to the middle-America conservatives demographic. These are
not the same people who watch Kardashians and "Real Housewives."

...Vin

/end thread

Jameson Teqkilla

In light of Vin's points and the gun quote I change my answer to yes

newwil7l

We don't need the nonsense she brings, so yes

ClashAndBurn

Yes, and death threats are honestly enough for any regular person to be thrown in jail.

Rico Shameless v2

I don't believe it was a publicity stunt like people want to believe. Nicki was being personal. She's unprofessional and should be let go.

NEUTRON

Quote:

Originally posted by Vin

One could even argue that Nicki Minaj and this drama is actually tarnishing American Idol's
brand. It's interesting that people feel they will promote this feud, but that probably will
not be the case, because "drama" isn't American Idol's claim to fame. American
Idol caters to the middle-America conservatives demographic. These are
not the same people who watch Kardashians and "Real Housewives."

...Vin

True but that's not how Idol sees things anymore. They want the drama to spark interest in the viewers like X Factor and The Voice.

H-I-M

Quote:

Originally posted by H-I-M

And what if Nicki gets physical during a LIVE show ?

Quote:

Our sources say ... in the heat of the argument, Nicki said, "If I had a gun I would shoot her."

The Queen ain't safe anymore

Rico Shameless v2

Quote:

Originally posted by Vin

One could even argue that Nicki Minaj and this drama is actually tarnishing American Idol's
brand. It's interesting that people feel they will promote this feud, but that probably will
not be the case, because "drama" isn't American Idol's claim to fame. American
Idol caters to the middle-America conservatives demographic. These are
not the same people who watch Kardashians and "Real Housewives."

...Vin

Exactly. The elderly in Colorado won't be here for it.

Phoenixstar

Yes,
-she's unprofessional behaviour
-She's way rude
-Someone us rude to her, she should let it go
And of course, she is not getting fired, cause she brings more views and rating

Taste of Honey

If she's talking about taking a gun and killing her, oh definately. It does NOT get that serious.

NEUTRON

I still believe its a stunt...

American Idol is too wholesome in lieu of these other talent shows nowadays...

XFactor has Simon
The Voice has Adam vs. Christina

And now Idol has Mariah vs. Nicki.

diamonds

nicki should be fired for dragging mariah back to the realisation of how irrelevant and floppy she is now? no... i don't even like nicki but... no

Rico Shameless v2

Quote:

Originally posted by Mr Telephone Man

No, she didn't act up for no reason. If Mariah was constantly patronizing her and picking on her, doesn't that amount to "bullying". Both that and fighting aren't good for the workplace.

So she should get fired for standing up for herself? But Mariah should get off for verbally assaulting her first? Whatever you may think of Nicki the artist, the video MORE than supports that this is an ongoing problem she has had to deal with against Mariah

So no, if Mariah gets off. So should she.

We don't even KNOW what Mariah said to "patronize" her. I can already sense Nicki blew up because Mariah said something shady, but extremely harmless. You can't put cursing and threatening "off with your head" on the same level as some sly ****.

Dark Matter

Mariah is more likely to go tbh.

BSNMology

Quote:

Originally posted by Vin

One could even argue that Nicki Minaj and this drama is actually tarnishing American Idol's
brand. It's interesting that people feel they will promote this feud, but that probably will
not be the case, because "drama" isn't American Idol's claim to fame. American
Idol caters to the middle-America conservatives demographic. These are
not the same people who watch Kardashians and "Real Housewives."

...Vin

Maybe in the days of Kelly Clarkson and Carrie Underwood when the show still had steam and dignity.

But from everyone to Jermaine, who they humiliated on camera with his arrest warrant drama, to Frenchie and her controversial past, American Idol recently is no stranger to drama.

This is just the first MAJOR judges' dispute. And that's arguable, because Paula got into it with everyone all the time. And that Kara girl and Simon.

It's just two females so everyone is overreacting now.

NEUTRON

Quote:

Originally posted by Rico Shameless v2

We don't even KNOW what Mariah said to "patronize" her. I can already sense Nicki blew up because Mariah said something shady, but extremely harmless. You can't put cursing and threatening "off with your head" on the same level as some sly ****.

EXACTLY... YOU DONT KNOW.

So HOW can you cast stones at Nicki without the entire story?

Thats like someone saying the US had no right kill Osama Bin Laden without knowing he initially caused 9/11.

I'm not saying Nicki is 100% in the right. But NO ONE just goes off on someone out of the clear blue sky for no reason.

Jennifer

No. I 150% KNOW Mariah provoked her.

Mimi is far and away the most INSECURE, catty, passive aggressive **** in the business. The hood in Nicki came out because she couldn't take the BS anymore. When your own coworker hangs up the phone after hearing you're being considered for the job, how would you feel?

They both are a damn mess but let's not blame Nicki for all of it, anyone with half a brain or any knowledge of Mariah's career/personality knows the deal here.