Isn't Marry The Night her ONLY flop tho, Judas reached top 10 atleast

I choose Judas still, the longevity was underwhelming and I STILL bop to it daily

Marry The Night, it was a fan favourite, had lots of promotion and charted worse than Not Myself Tonight

Judas I thought people were gonna eat it up because of the hype when it was released.

Judas should've taken BTW's place tbqfh.

Judas did not flop

Australian Singles Chart[54] 6
Austrian Singles Chart[59] 6
Belgian Singles Chart (Flanders)[59] 6
Belgian Singles Chart (Wallonia)[59] 4
Brazilian Hot 100 Airplay[111] 2
Brazil Billboard Pop Songs[112] 2
Canadian Hot 100[49] 8
Croatian Airplay Radio Chart[113] 2
Czech Airplay Chart[114] 10
Danish Singles Chart[59] 10
Dutch Top 40[115] 24
Finnish Singles Chart[58] 3
French Singles Chart[54] 7
Hungarian Singles Chart[116] 3
Irish Singles Chart[57] 4
Israeli Airplay Chart[117] 6
Italian Singles Chart[118] 3
Japan Hot 100[119] 3
New Zealand Singles Chart[55] 12
Norwegian Singles Chart[59] 3
Russian Download Chart[120] 9
Scottish Singles Chart[121] 5
Slovak Airplay Chart[122] 4
South Korean International Singles Chart[123] 1
Spanish Singles Chart[124] 6
Swedish Singles Chart[59] 7
Swiss Singles Chart[59] 8
UK Singles Chart[52] 8
US Billboard Hot 100[40] 10
US Hot Dance Club Songs[44] 1
US Pop Songs[42] 15

Marry The Night, but to be honest people weren't hear for that 10+ minute video in which the song wasn't played until the end.

Judas, especially after the BTW success

Marry the Night.
But her other flops are dissapointing as well.

Marry The Night is her only flop so that one!

Judas may not be a flop in peaks postions but its sales are lackluster (at least in US) however her biggest flop was MTN considering it didn't chart in some countries and in the ones it did, it did poorly.

I thought "chart positions were nothing"

Regarding popularity, impact, relevance and memorability... It clearly was. I do love the song though.

Her only flop, MTN.

Well, Judas was kind of a flop compared to Gaga's own expectations. If I remember correctly she praised it before its release as the biggest hit of her album of the decade...

Judas was a flop
A shame since it's her best song

everyone was expecting judas to be the **** but it never happened. no1curr about "marry the flop" though.

Judas seemed like an international hit but in the U.S. it peaked early and didn't have as much radio support as her other singles.
MTN was bound to happen with a music video like that.

That was the summer song of 2010
Peaked at #3 on BB if I believe correctly.