almost feeling like a proud mama stanning for her the whole year and watching her grow better and better with her live performances. she's miles away from the SNL-debacle now.

Her voice is shaky and out of tune... I like her, but she's a horrible vocalist.

Charming

She is not a technical singer, more of a chanteuse. Arrgh, but why I'm arguing on ATRL?

Her voice was technically out of tune during some moments and it was very shaky at the start. There are rules for singing and she's not following them, that's all i'm saying.

Just like it sounds on record, that's just her style of singing but her voice is also very gloomy and exquisite. She is not a good vocalist indeed but she's far from terrible.

Beautiful.

She was a bit shaky at the start with Blue Velvet but she recovered.

I guess the 3 million people that bought her album don't really care for the rules then.

I think she sounds lovely and haunting live.

I agree, her control and confidence has really grown to be worthy of the spoitlight she has! Good on her.

I was so distracted with those damn people talking

Yes, I know. Few people care about rules, which is why so many talent less people rule the airwaves. Not saying she is, I think she is talented songwriter. Doesn't mean I won't mention that her voice was out of tune and horrible shaky. It is what it is. If you don't care, good for you. I do. I hope she gets better at it.

I don't hear where she is "shaky and out of tune". Listen to it with a good headphone and I think she sounds just as she does in the recorded version.

she must be a punk of the vocal world and doesn't really care about rules.

When she tried to be a proper singer in New York singing jazz, she didn't really go anywhere.

It's only when she experimented with her lower range was when she got attention, but she has sang with so many different vocal styles over the years.

This really does sound different with headphone's on, good ones. It's pretty weird tbh