Duff Performance of "Fly"

vs.


Lohan's "Over"


ON MY PERSONAL OPINION:
lohan is 100% live while Duff lipsync on chorus!

duuff

^ thanks for the vote udesai93

Duff performance was lipsync

^ only in the chorus

lohan's performance was TOTALLY LIVE!
Lindsay of course

Lohan

Lohan

Hilary!!!!!

Obviously, Lindsay.

i like hilary's acting on chorus "she covers her ear"

Lindsay... at least she was singing LIVE the whole song... (but both songs are boring)

Well actually I asked my friend who litterally hates her and works and the AOL music department. He told me that it was 100% live because hilary and her manager wanted it to be or something like that

^so Hilary sang it live?

^ but listen to her voice at the verse and chorus
the chorus sounded like in the CD

yea i guess it was too good to be true

Ok, I will do my choice between I saw on the perfomance, not the voice because their voices are amazing so i have to choose Miss Lohan because at least she move herself, and Hilary stayed all the time in the front of the microphone nothing more!

^ what a great Portuguese Idol judge
yeah hilary just stand there

At least duff realized she couldn't sing so she lipsynced thew chorus. Lohan even though she was 100% live, she sucked. I would like to pick neither, but I'll pick duff.