First Time sounds like a typical BLG song which I like.
Be Your Everything is nice too but it kinda sounds like a Marianas Trench song, I also find Martin's vocals here to be similar to Josh Ramsay.
I find Life of the Party catchy but weird. It doesn't sound like a song they would sing but I think it's pretty cool.
I like it!!! I was getting kind of a country feel to their songs, especially during "The First TIme". I can't wait for the rest of their album. Sounds like they are trying to change their style/sound, but in a good way.