The lowdown: Taylor has yet to recover from a relationship that she did not expect to end in this thunderous (and pained) pop aria. The twelfth track on Speak Now, it is one of the album's darkest cuts, both sonically and emotionally.
The vote: Seven votes of 5 or below were offset by twice as many 10's, allowing "Haunted" to soar into the top ten, surpassing all but one of Taylor's other songs along the way.
Best line: "He would try to take away my pain.../but the whole time I'm wishing he was you instead"
. 
