Umbrella was released before the explosion of the digital era

Other singles before the digital era sold more than PF, as well. That's no excuse

I think its clear that both songs were huge. The poll is tied

Let's see who wins

Poker face!

I said explosion. Umbrella's sales were still digital not physical.

So why should we care she didn't release it physical?

Anyway, Umbrella. Its impact ion unparalleled by any of the other popstars' singles except maybe for britney.

Bad Romance or We Found Love only wish they could cause this much tension in a thread

I prefer Umbrella. Poker Face is good though.

I voted Umbrella by mistake

I'm a stan of neither artists, but I think Umbrella is better and bigger. I don't think Poker Face won a Grammy tho.

Poker Face, Mediatraffic agrees.

Umbrella, Grammy agrees

I voted for one of the iconic songs of the 2000's

So which one?

It won one actually and noms as SOTY & ROTY.

Anyway in Mexico both songs were massive, Umbrella a little bit bigger but it's not played that much while I still listen PF on radio, tv, etc.

Umbrella's impact >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>