Source

It's sad her 'Coulda Been' song seems a bit ironic now, she had some good songs tbh

She's not popular enough to be a judge.

Randy Jackson is/was?... I'm not being sarcastic.. I'm just wondering. I don't know who she is tho.

She had so much potential.

She was and still is so talented. It's a shame her label and MGT team sucked hard.

I loved her songs 8th World Wonder and Change. Change used to slay me. THe album it was on was pretty good too.

8th World Wonder was ****ing epic

Slayed me so hard

Randy Jackson is much more popular. Not only has he produced music for Mariah Carey, Celine, and Madonna (to name a few), he is a Grammy winner who played with Carlos Santana, Jerry Garcia, and was also in the band Journey for a year. He is pretty well known and respected.

I really like her but no one is here for her. She may be able to bring a great perspective and insight, but the producers won't give her a chance. They are trying to bring in ratings gold.

American Idol should call Usher for that job.

Anyway back to the topic, I think Kimberly would be a good judge, but I don't think American Idol won't give her a shot because they want someone who as or even more popular than Demi now. They already went to paid a lot of money to a legend "Mariah Carey" to be toe to toe with X factor judge Britney Spears.

She can forget it.

I'd like to see her on it, I was rooting for her way back in season 2. She has a great voice and image. Too bad they won't pick her though.

No but he was a pioneer. Kimberly (I think) was a contestant of American Idol. With the current celebrity judges, I don't think she has what it takes.