Which American Idol had the best 1st single from his/her debut CD?


From Taylor Hicks's self-titled CD - Just to Feel That Way


From Katherine McPhee's self-titled CD - Over It


From Chris Daughtry's band, Daughtry's self-titled CD- It's Not Over


From Kellie Pickler's CD, Small Town Girl - Red High Heels

Plus, I did a little Wikipedia research and found out that Elliot Yamin as well as Paris Bennett are each supposed to have a CD released this March.

where are the most succesfull one? =D
Kelly and Carrie?

haven't heard any, sorry

Chris!

Katharine McPhee , follow up by Chris Daughtry

You can read the tittle of the thread... these idols are from season 5. Kelly is from S1 and Carrie from S4... but anyway the best single is "It's Not Over"

1st : DAUGHTRY
2nd: KATHERINE MCPHEE
3rd: KELLIE PICKLER
4th: TAYLOR HICKS

1st: draw betwen Daughtry & Katharine
3rd: Kellie

laaaaaast: Taylor

Um...cannot stand Kelly's, never heard Taylor's and Kat's makes me want to punch a nun.

So Daughtry and his overwroght Rob Thomas impression wins by default!

100% Agree

oh, sorry

i understood idols from the 5 seasons, sorry.
I just get lost afet ruben

1. Over It
2. Red High Heels
3. It's Not Over
...
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
..
.
.
..
.
.
.
4. WHO ELSE?! You name it.


Yeap, Elliott, Paris, and Mandisa have albums coming up!
I heard Ace, too.

1. chris daughtry
2. kath
3. taylor
4. kellie

Over it - kath!

Over It, but It's Not Over is a close second.

what's about CARRIE UNDERWOOD?
#1--Taylor Hicks
#2--Katherine

Taylor is pure crap.. how could he have won

Carrie's from AI Season 4!
This thread says about Season 5!

I pick Kat's song Over It.

1) Red High Heels
2) Over It
3) It's Not Over
4) Just To Feel That Way

Stop bringing up Carrie, she was in Season 4 and this clearly says Season 5!!!! ahaha

Elliott, Paris and Bucky have been signed and have albums coming out shortly. The rest are just recording and shopping around for deals!

it's not over is a nice song, but i pick over it